Feig already has 3 successful movies with women playing the main leads. While GB certainly will certainly create ripples for Lesly and McKinnon, I doubt it will stop the ‘gender equality’ already in progress, should the movie turn out disappointing in the eye of the general public.
I have trouble imagining Ghostbusters can tank, but that’s just me.
At least the RoboCop remake didn’t have millions of adults complaining on Facebook and Twitter. Many of them were actually open to the remake. They’ve also had like 3 other actors who played RoboCop after Peter Weller, so I guess they’re use to new actors taking the role. Contrast to here, where apparently Ghostbusters can only be Murray, Aykroyd, Ramis, and Hudson. I know a few people who never even saw the original Ghostbusters, but think the remake looks fun.
Like it or not, the reboot will generate interest in the franchise. That’s a good thing. The A-Team film wasn’t successful, but it got many people interested in the show.
There’s a bit of a difference. Peter Weller didn’t create RoboCop, also aside from cult classics like Naked Lunch and Buckaroo Banzai, he didn’t become a household name. Though he is a great underrated actor. But back to my original statement, he didn’t create RoboCop.
Ghostbusters on the other hand, was created by 2 of the 4 cast members, plus the director. Not to mention these guys have been associated with each other since the early 70s during their National Lampoon Hour days and Second City. So it has a bit more of a personal film aesthetic to it.
There was also more substance before and after Ghostbusters. We got Groundhog Day, Spies like Us, Analyze This, Lost in Translation, etc. The original guys became comic screen legends. It’s only natural that most people feel the film incarnations of Ghostbusters should belong to them.
Especially. When a remake of one their works is a very blatant corporate attempt to buy in on the product name. Most people saw through this and spoke against it ..why is that wrong? (Aside from the twitter trolls)
It’s not wrong to speak against it, but it’s also not wrong to like the reboot.
Guys, we all have solid opinionated reasons for and against this movie.
One thing I know: if GB16 was not a reboot it would not have been made and we would still be waiting for all parties involved to find a way to make it all happen just like they were trying for years and years. Which meant no ghost corps. Nothing. It could very well be the end for the entire franchise.
Because of GB16 getting made the franchise is becoming stronger and stronger because it’s making money again. We have Ecto cooler, Madame Tussaud’s, and cartoons, toys, books and other stories in the works. The gears are spinning and all we need to do is to be willing to share the experience: there is also stuff coming for you. You just have to wait a little longer.
Yeah, love or hate Feig and/or the movie – he’s essentially the Dutch boy taking his finger out and letting the dam break wide open. The contribution he’ll be remembered for won’t be the movie, it’ll be giving the franchise the jump start we’ve all been waiting for. More movies, a cartoon, books, the comic, toys, Twinkies. Everyone will know who to call again.
Great interview with Feig. The man seems to have understand what irks some of us and give great sincere answers.
I wish he had done such an interview months ago.
That’s a great interview. They really touch upon a lot of the biggest gripes some people have.
For me however, the biggest thing I liked, and I liked most answers, was the interviewer saying:
One thing I wasn’t quite expecting – although I got this with the first film too – there was a moment in it that was really spooky, and I jumped out of my seat.
And this reboot hasn’t tried to make anyone forget that.
Thing is audiences pick and choose which corporate schemes to see through. If they like a movie, it’s declared a masterpiece, not matter how foolish such a label may be. If they dislike a movie, suddenly they’re all wise to corporate deceptions, heh.
That’s it right there. It’s called confirmation bias. “I don’t like this” becomes, “no matter how great it may be, I don’t want to flip-flop and crush my integrity, therefore, I HATE it.”
Hollywood, music, professional sports… It’s ALL a corporate scheme. Even the most independent of art, it’s all motivated by those little federal reserve notes (or whatever form of currency exists on your side of the planet). It’s an ugly truth that people seem to be ignore until it suits them.
Just about damn well everything has an agenda attached to it.
There’s a bit of a difference. Peter Weller didn’t create RoboCop, also aside from cult classics like Naked Lunch and Buckaroo Banzai, he didn’t become a household name. Though he is a great underrated actor. But back to my original statement, he didn’t create RoboCop.
Murray didn’t create Venkman. Hudson didn’t create Zeddemore, yet they complain about him as being one of the only Ghostbusters. That leaves only two who they should complain about because they were the only actors who actually “created” there characters.
Also, an actor does have a part in creating the character. They are the ones that bring the character to life. The writer didn’t script how RoboCop would walk, that was Weller who planned it. The writer didn’t script how his body would show emotion without talking, that was Weller. Arnold Schwarzenegger didn’t create the Terminator either, yet so many people say only he could play the part. The same thing can be applied to the new Star Trek. The original actors didn’t write the characters, yet you’ll still have people saying only they can play them.
Ghostbusters on the other hand, was created by 2 of the 4 cast members, plus the director. Not to mention these guys have been associated with each other since the early 70s during their National Lampoon Hour days and Second City. So it has a bit more of a personal film aesthetic to it.
That same motion can be applied to any other film. Ghostbusters isn’t any special exception. Many films have personal aesthetics marked by the director and cast. Cameron and Burton films definitely have a certain style to them. The same argument was made by A-Team fans who said only Peppard, Schultz, Mr. T and Benedict could play them because the actors had their own personal touch to the role.
There was also more substance before and after Ghostbusters. We got Groundhog Day, Spies like Us, Analyze This, Lost in Translation, etc.
We also got Nothing but Trouble, Blues Brothers 2000, Yogi Bear, Garfield, Chaddyshack 2, etc. Great classics films there…
It’s only natural that most people feel the film incarnations of Ghostbusters should belong to them.
Only because that’s what we saw first. Many people who grew up watching George Reeves play Superman feel he was the best. People who grew up with Christopher Reeve feel he was best actor to don the cape. The only natural thing about this is our minds wanting what we’re used to. Besides, they’re different characters. The original incarnation exists regardless of this films outcome.
Especially. When a remake of one their works is a very blatant corporate attempt to buy in on the product name.
Like the sequel which was written to buy in on a product name? Oh wait, it’s written by the original writers so it gets exempted (yes, that’s how they reasoned it).
It’s funny how people keep mentioning “cash-ins” as a reason to hate, when the only reason the original film was made to generate cash. When the new cartoon got announced they said the same thing. EVERYTHING is made to generate money.
Only because that’s what we saw first. Many people who grew up watching George Reeves play Superman feel he was the best. People who grew up with Christopher Reeve feel he was best actor to don the cape. The only natural thing about this is our minds wanting what we’re used to. Besides, they’re different characters. The original incarnation exists regardless of this films outcome.
Other examples along this line are James Bond, and the Doctor from Doctor Who. There are people who honest to God think that George Lazenby (the one-off actor who played Bond in On Her Majesty’s Secret Service) is the best person to play the role, even though the greater majority feel he was a terrible actor and Bond. A person’s favourite incarnation of the Doctor can depend greatly on which one they grew up with, mine was Sylvester McCoy (though for others he embodies the show in an era where [I]Doctor Who was in decline).
There almost certainly were people who thought Patrick Troughton (the second Doctor) couldn’t replace the original, William Hartnell, but he has his following of fans even to this day, to the point where some even dress up as him.
And I guess that’s what things will end up being like, something akin to [I]Doctor Who[I], where there are fans of the classic and the new stuff, fans who are only fans of one or the other, and people who like the new, the classic and the expanded universe stuff, even if it isn’t entirely or remotely canon with the main series. ![]()
Murray didn’t create Venkman. Hudson didn’t create Zeddemore, yet they complain about him as being one of the only Ghostbusters. That leaves only two who they should complain about because they were the only actors who actually “created” there characters.
Also, an actor does have a part in creating the character. They are the ones that bring the character to life. The writer didn’t script how RoboCop would walk, that was Weller who planned it. The writer didn’t script how his body would show emotion without talking, that was Weller. Arnold Schwarzenegger didn’t create the Terminator either, yet so many people say only he could play the part. The same thing can be applied to the new Star Trek. The original actors didn’t write the characters, yet you’ll still have people saying only they can play them.
That same motion can be applied to any other film. Ghostbusters isn’t any special exception. Many films have personal aesthetics marked by the director and cast. Cameron and Burton films definitely have a certain style to them. The same argument was made by A-Team fans who said only Peppard, Schultz, Mr. T and Benedict could play them because the actors had their own personal touch to the role.
We also got Nothing but Trouble, Blues Brothers 2000, Yogi Bear, Garfield, Chaddyshack 2, etc. Great classics films there…
Only because that’s what we saw first. Many people who grew up watching George Reeves play Superman feel he was the best. People who grew up with Christopher Reeve feel he was best actor to don the cape. The only natural thing about this is our minds wanting what we’re used to. Besides, they’re different characters. The original incarnation exists regardless of this films outcome.
Like the sequel which was written to buy in on a product name? Oh wait, it’s written by the original writers so it gets exempted (yes, that’s how they reasoned it).
It’s funny how people keep mentioning “cash-ins” as a reason to hate, when the only reason the original film was made to generate cash. When the new cartoon got announced they said the same thing. EVERYTHING is made to generate money.
Yeah, i know actors have a lot of creative reigns to flesh out the character that they were chosen to play. That’s essentially the whole point of a performance..so..thanks? ![]()
Second of all, I LOVE Nothing But Trouble. it’s highly underrated, i suggest giving it another watch. Dark comedies didnt really go over well back then, (hell, even Beeteljuice got slammed back then ) Aykroyd is hilarious as the villain, Judge Alvin.
you say “great classic films there…”
It’s pretty petty to point out all the stinkers of ones career. look its easy, i’ll apply it to Feig and McCarthy…“Unaccompanied Minors”, “Tammy”, “The Boss”. there ya go! ![]()
And why is it common practice now to downplay the original filmmakers in order to defend the remake? shrugs
I was merely making an example, that the original guys made a cultural impact, not just as Ghostbusters. These guys were comedy all-stars before the GB-craze even existed. Which is why i think that alot of people arent taking the ‘reboot’ too well. It’s got some really huge shoes to fill in terms of legacy.
You can’t really compare the GBs to something like Superman. thats like comparing the Marx Brothers to the X-men. GB wasn’t an adaptation of a comic book or previous source. Also, I don’t think its a matter of ‘who played who first’.
Of course GB2 was a easy cash ride, Again, why do we slam the original films to defend the new one? And yes, because it was the original crew, does KIND OF mean its gets exempt in some aspects. they weren’t trying to capitalize on someone else’s work, they were trying to build on something they already created, nothing wrong with building off of your own success. They at least TRIED to make a funny movie. some disagree, but i love GB2.
Well yeah, all projects are made to generate money, thats why its called the entertainment BUSINESS. but when you create a shallow product with no substance, people notice, especially when its an attempt to recreate something that’s already great to begin with. All albums are made to generate record sales, and theres a HUGE difference between a Clash album and a Justin Beiber album.
some disagree, but i love GB2.
Me too!
The court room scene from gb2 is one of my favorites from either movie. Even if gb16 is a good movie Theres alot of resistance and with star trek coming out the following weekend im guessing it will lead to bad box offfice numbers.. I wish they would had promoted ivan defending the movie from the get. Asking the fans to give the movie a chance , its good , trailers arent a good representation.. Sits better with me than the back and forth attacks between the fans and sony.
The minute they call it Ghostbusters its hard not to compare it to the originals and judge gb16 on its own. Gb2 is a good movie, disappointments come from comparison to the first movie. Like some of the previous comments, your experiences growing up have to affect your perception. Reminds me of the ewok line from how i met your mother:
The Ewok Line correlates the birth year of a person and the subsequent appreciation of Ewoks, fictional teddy bear-like creatures from the 1983 film Return of the Jedi. Those born on or before May 25, 1973 have a low appreciation of the film’s creatures, while those born after this date have an affinity for them. This is because those who saw the Ewoks in Return of the Jedi, which was released theatrically on May 25, 1983, who were 10 or under still loved their teddy bears, giving them an increased appreciation for the Ewoks.
Yeah, i know actors have a lot of creative reigns to flesh out the character that they were chosen to play. That’s essentially the whole point of a performance..so..thanks?
You said Peter Weller didn’t create RoboCop so it didn’t matter if someone else played him. I was pointing out that the actor does indeed a have part in its creating the character, so it does matter. Marty McFly probably wouldn’t have been as memorable if he was played by Eric Stoltz in the final film.
Second of all, I LOVE Nothing But Trouble. it’s highly underrated, i suggest giving it another watch.
I have. I didn’t’ think it was that good. It was ok, but nothing I would say is a must watch. Critically, it wasn’t well received either.
And why is it common practice now to downplay the original filmmakers in order to defend the remake? shrugs
It isn’t. But that doesn’t mean we should ignore any faults that exist. The problem is when people downplay the remake with comparisons that are easily applied to the original, but are ignored solely because “they were the original so it gets a pass”.
I was merely making an example, that the original guys made a cultural impact, not just as Ghostbusters. These guys were comedy all-stars before the GB-craze even existed.
I don’t think the cast had a big cultural impact at that point yet. Bill Murray certainly was one of the draws, Dan Aykroyd had Blues Brothers. Harold Ramis had a starring role in Stripes, but most of his stuff was directing, writing and Second City Television. Saturday Night live was the most they had in common. Ghostbusters probably pushed them to cultural impact before anything else, aside from Dan Aykroyd with Blue Brothers of course.
For any remake film you’re going to have big shoes to fill, and the comparison will be made regardless of who plays them.
You can’t really compare the GBs to something like Superman. thats like comparing the Marx Brothers to the X-men. GB wasn’t an adaptation of a comic book or previous source. Also, I don’t think its a matter of ‘who played who first’.
It very much is a matter of “who we saw play who first.” It doesn’t matter if it wasn’t adapted from something previously, our perception automatically goes to the original cast because that’s who we saw first. We’re use to them, so it’s hard for us to see anyone else in the role. If they had an actor that wasn’t as well regarded today as Murray playing Venkman, the reaction would be the same. There are actually some who prefer The Real Ghostbusters cast more than the film cast, and usually it’s because they grew up watching the cartoons first. As pointed out for Doctor Who and James Bond, the preferred actor is typically based on which one we saw first. I saw Christopher Reeve as Superman first, so to me he is Superman. I get sense of nostalgia whenever I see a photo of him in that costume. I don’t get the same feeling for Dean Caine or George Reeves (though they are both good in their own right). The same thing will probably happen for the remake.
Of course GB2 was a easy cash ride, Again, why do we slam the original films to defend the new one? And yes, because it was the original crew, does KIND OF mean its gets exempt in some aspects. they weren’t trying to capitalize on someone else’s work, they were trying to build on something they already created, nothing wrong with building off of your own success.
No one is slamming the original films. It’s merely being pointed out that while you keep saying the remake is a cash-in, that was also the exact case for the second film. Aykroyd and Ramis had no intention of doing a sequel in the first place. The film was made because the new studio head pressured them into making a sequel because they wanted an easy sell. The first thing she wanted was to start production on Ghostbusters II and Karate Kid II. Not because she had good story in mind, but because the first made money, and was banking on the sequels to make easy cash. This is why people writing articles are saying (some) fans completely biased about the situation. You write off anything by the original guys like it’s a sacred and can’t be criticized.
They at least TRIED to make a funny movie.
Which is what the remake trying to do. You may not find the humor funny, but others may think differently. There are some who think the original isn’t that funny either. Feig has shown that his type of humor works for a certain crowd, and all his interviews say he tried to make the funniest film he could.
Well yeah, all projects are made to generate money, thats why its called the entertainment BUSINESS. but when you create a shallow product with no substance, people notice, especially when its an attempt to recreate something that’s already great to begin with..
Like GB2 was? While the fan community may have a positive look on the second film, outside, the film is considered mediocre at best. It’s generally considered a shallow product with little substance that tries to recreate what the first film did. That’s what many critics thought of it. I know it seems like I’m hating the second film, but I’m just saying all your comparisons to the remake being shallow can be applied the second film as well. It shouldn’t get exempted just because the original guys wrote it. I don’t hate GB2. I thought it was pretty fun, but in a lot of ways, it was a mini-remake of the first film.
I don’t think the cast had a big cultural impact at that point yet. Bill Murray certainly was one of the draws, Dan Aykroyd had Blues Brothers. Harold Ramis had a starring role in Stripes, but most of his stuff was directing, writing and Second City Television. Saturday Night live was the most they had in common. Ghostbusters probably pushed them to cultural impact before anything else, aside from Dan Aykroyd with Blue Brothers of course.
I think Saturday Night Live and Blues Brothers did have the big cultural impact we’re talking about. But that was a mere 5 years when they were hip, subversive 20 year olds. How do you obtain the all important staying power? Well it doesn’t hurt to become beloved icons for children in the following decades, I don’t think that can be underestimated. Ghostbusters is like Wizard of Oz in that way, there’s always another generation to discover it.
And why is it common practice now to downplay the original filmmakers in order to defend the remake? shrugs
Sometimes people do that, and I agree it’s annoying, but other times they’re just trying to stop the romanticism that fans develop around certain movies or actors. That’s not putting them down, that’s just bringing them back to Earth.
It’s been my stance for a while now that I don’t like any of Paul Feig’s other movies. I liked Freaks and Geeks well enough, but that was close to 20 years ago.
Must be because Ivan did Fathers Day that was a remake of an 80’s French comedy that didn’t do that well.
Harold also made a remake Bedazzled of an even older film of the same name. Although his remake actually did well.