I agree that Ghostbusters needs to lean a bit more into horror than it has in every film since the first entry in 1984.
Part of what made the original so compelling was that working stiffs going up against legitimately unsettling circumstances. The terror dogs were extremely effective in the first film and establishing stakes. That’s what made the dry comedy so impactful—it offered a release to the tension that adversaries like the Library Ghost was able to create.
Lord knows the world is full of all kinds of horrors these days. Give people an outlet for that. Let them see non-superhero characters go up against truly terrifying situations and overcome them. I suspect that’s why Ghostbusters resonated with kids so much. In an era of horror films and satanic panic, Ghostbusters told a generation not to be afraid. Ghostbusters told kids (and adults) that we can find ways to know the unknowable, and overcome world-threatening situations.
(hell, Ghostbusters is the reason I’ve been on three disaster relief deployments this year)
The franchise—if not entirely rebooted at this point—also needs to do new things in general.
Ghostbusters has always transcended genre by being a blend of many different ones—but one of the genres has always been sci-fi. While unearthing equipment from the '80s in Oklahoma in Afterlife worked, seeing that same aging tech in modern day Manhattan for the entirety of Frozen Empire was not credible.
As Ivan Reitman repeatedly emphasized, the effectiveness of Ghostbusters relies on believability. Simply slapping yellow parts on to equipment developed in an era of floppy discs just… wasn’t believable. Hell, even Extreme Ghostbusters knew enough to update the tech back in 1997.
Leverage horror, and give creators a shot at making something new to reflect where our culture now is. Yes, it will change what the franchise is. But that’s the only growth will occur.
