In the Ghostbusters Vintage Collectors group on Facebook, Jenna Edmunds reported that only after opening her three cans did she notice numbers stamped into each can.

I had three cans I hadn’t yet opened, so I made sure to note which can each Mini came from.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vN-rWBMObOw
Other people including Kyle Baker commented on Jenna’s post, which allowed me to deduce a fourth can.
Right now the ‘known’ numbers are:
01 melting Puft
02
03 drummer Puft
04 rocket Puft
05
06 pencil Puft
UPDATE: According to Steven T. Lawrence, the 02 can will yield the chocolate-eating Puft and the 05 can contains the fiery Puft!

So the revised list would be:
01 melting Puft
02 chocolate-eating Puft
03 drummer Puft
04 rocket Puft
05 fiery Puft
06 pencil Puft
Alex
