Ouch!
This is gonna get some people arguing that’s for sure!
Here is the situation:
GBTVG (Realistic version) was considered canon (due to comments by Dan Aykroyd that he really considered it the original GB3 and the fact that he and Ramis worked on the script).
Later, Afterlife showed some discrepancies with GBTVG (Realistic version) (with Gozer returning and the whole Shandor thing).
On face value GBTVG (Realistic version) and Afterlife seemed to be (somewhat) incompatible which led to some saying saying GBTVG (RV) was no longer canon. MANY fans here (especially those who don’t really have an interest in gaming) went with that statement. It was an official statement afterall.
But for people (like me) who were and are deeply in love with GBTVG (RV) we have a hard time letting that go so easily.
The fact that it is an official release, having had script input from Aykroyd and Ramis (the original script writers of GB1), is the final release where all 4 Ghostbusters are in an adventure together, is a straight up sequel to GB2 set just 2 years later, is 60 hrs (at least) and has YOU experience it from within, interacting with the actual Ghostbusters, was just too good to be true. Especially being released 20 years after the last movie installment.
It released really out of the blue, featuring almost the entire GB1 cast of actual actors (Murray, Aykroyd, Ramis, Hudson, Potts and Atherton). That was a miracle.
What made it even more miraculous was the quality and fan service in the game. Every little part of it oozed the fact that it was made by real fans of the franchise and not a corporation. It is a benchmark on how to make a videogame out of a movie franchise.
That’s the situation. Eventhough officially Sony has (I think still) decanonised it, for those of us that love it, we go by Aykroyds word.
And yeah you can kind of make it fit Afterlife with saying that Gozer was fooling Shandor all along and ripped him in half the moment she saw him because of what happened in the video game.
It’s uncharacteristic for Gozer to kill someone the moment he/she encounters them (i.e. when the GB’s met Gozer in GB1 or the Phoebe/ Gozer scene in Afterlife.) Yet Gozer ripped Shandor in half the moment it laid eyes on him. Also Shandor looks identical in Afterlife as he did in GBTVG.
The driver of the Ecto1 in the final scene of Afterlife, who drives it into the Firehouse also suspiciously has the Rookie’s (Bryan Welsh) look. Winston saying he started his business with “1” employee felt like a hug.
Instead of arguing it those of us that love it really try to get as many people to play it and fall in love with it as we have.
As for Spirits Unleased (while I love that game too) I have no data on that. The game doesn’t have a detailed or long story, being a multiplayer action game. On face value it seems to be harder to reconcile it being canon with the upcoming Firehouse unless they reference all the characters (Eddie, Cat, etc) in the new movie, which looks unlikely. To be honest GBTVG deserves to be referenced in Firehouse so much more than SU does. Simply because of the artistic franchise merit.