One thing that I worry about is: why when a fan express it’s doubts and concerns about the reboot the answers are always: “ah, don’t judge a movie before you see it!! You have to wait the finished product! You’re a hater!!” and when someone starts claiming that the reboot will surely be a great movie he doesn’t get the same answers (How can you say that? You haven’t see the movie yet!!) You know, the ones who hates the reboot idea hasn’t see the movie yet, that’s right…but this is the same also for the ones who loves Feig and his humor!
Shitting on something you don’t have enough information to shit on is just not a socially acceptable thing to do. It makes you an asshole, it hurts peoples feelings and it brings more negativity to the world and doesn’t accomplish anything positive.
Being optimistic about something you don’t have enough information to judge doesn’t do much of anything. Doesn’t hurt anyone and it doesn’t make our fandom look like a lot of insane, sexist manchildren.
Makes sense now, let’s remove the nasty ones. We have those like me who don’t like Feig’s direction but are fully aware that this is a way to relaunch the franchise and are hoping for Pearcebusters to come to fruition. Are we the good ones or the bad ones?
So pointing out that you don’t care for certain brands of humor makes you a sexist?
Ultimately this is a transaction no different than buying a car; you do your research and put the money down on the counter for the goods. I even went as far as watching one of Feig’s movies (Spy) and aside from the kitchen knife fight (which was great) and a few other set pieces I didn’t see anything that filled me with any enthusiasm.
I wish the cast and crew the best of luck but see no cause for blind cheerleading of product that has yet to be released.
Feel the same way about the new Star Wars movie; be nice to see a good movie after the last 3 stinkers but I’ll not hold my breath for it. J.J. can make a entertaining movie but the last two Star Trek movies did have thier flaws. The first was highly entertaining in spite of the flaws and have watched it several times.
Personally I think a GB movie where the original cast handed off to a younger generation would have the greatest chance of wide success. This reeks of Sony latching onto the “hottest new comedy director” and running with it.
Will it pan out for them? I hope so for the sake of the franchise.
Looking at a list of comedy movies I see several I really enjoyed the last few years, most of which I went in cold knowing nothing about them. Kingsmen was a riot, Antman was funny in a different subtle way, Zombieland was rediculous fun, RED was great and even the rom-com The Proposal scored high marks and I’m not a rom-com fan.
I think a Matthew Vaughn GB movie would have been interesting. Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels which he produced is one of my favorite comedy movies if a touch on the dark side for some folks.
It is all how the media handles it. Hating Feigbusters “means you hate women” is a very convenient way for the media to handle things. The media doesn’t go deeper than that.
I’m pretty sure a new Ghostbusters movie has been in development for quite a bit longer than the Sony leaked emails cover. Weren’t Aykroyd and Ramis both upfront about the '90s versions that were going to introduce then-hot comedians like Ben Stiller and Chris Farley as new Ghostbusters?
The problem, from what I can tell, including information detailed in the leaks, is that the studio was not particularly confident in a Ghostbusters sequel that would have Aykroyd and probably Ramis and Hudson, but not Murray, and they were struggling to find both a director they were confident who could tackle the project and actors that were willing to do it. Maybe in the ‘90s you could’ve talked Stiller and Farley into doing it, and maybe it seemed more likely they could sway Murray before he had his resurgence as a different kind of performer with Rushmore and Lost in Translation, but current comedians like Seth Rogen and Jonah Hill were clearly skeptical that the scripts they were getting reflected a movie that lived up to Ghostbusters’ legacy.
They’ve been trying to make this movie since at least the mid-‘90s. Ghostbusters has and remains a major property for them and one they’ve basically been unable to exploit beyond re-releasing the movies on home video and creating some merch, and even most of that merch is from the last ten years as the market for upscale action figures and things like that has exploded. There is no doubt that they considered making that movie many times over, in many different iterations, but they just weren’t confident enough in its prospect for success to make it, because it’d be a tentpole summer release, and Ghostbusters’ success over time is more based on the film’s quality than it is the box office cachet of the actors.
This is the same thing as the people trying to change #BlackLivesMatter to #AllLivesMatter. #BlackLivesMatter doesn’t mean “everyone else’s life is meaningless.” It’s a self-contained statement that makes a single point about a single group, and the exclusion of other points is not a criticism or dismissal of other points or groups. (Someone pointed out that if the slogan was “Children’s Lives Matter” nobody would go, “What about adults?”) So when the media talks about misogynists, it’s because the misogynists are out there. Nobody’s saying THE ENTIRE Ghostbusters fandom is corrupted by this, but all of US are IN the fandom, where we get to see a range of opinions. Trolls tend to be persistent and one-note. For the people actually making the movie, they’re getting hit with this kind of stuff all the time. Even if it’s not the majority of the responses, it’s neverending – every minute or so, some person decides to Tweet something angrily at Feig and that person joins X number of other people who just arrived at the same decision, and those are just the people who Tweet once or twice, and then move on.
When the reboot was new I saw some truly vile garbage in these communities. I saw an image meme of Janine that said something to the effect of “Ghostbusters was better when women only answered the phone!” We don’t see that as often now because some of the fervor has died down and moderators have rightfully ousted the outright hateful and mean-spirited, but those people didn’t cease to be. They’re still out there, likely continuing to harp on about this stuff. It’s the same with gaming. Just because maybe you have reached a point where you don’t see it, having picked your friends wisely, it doesn’t mean it goes away. It just becomes an undercurrent, and some of that stuff, like the guy hounding Feig on Twitter, that comes to light. It’s not like the media can publish a list each time of who’s an inclusive fan or who isn’t. You have to feel confident in your own choices.
This is a double fallacy: that it matters more what women think just because the movie stars women, and that any number a single person could know is statistically significant.
I am a man, but I gravitate toward movies about women. There are plenty of women who gravitate toward movies about men. Some women like movies that I would consider misogynistic. Some women would consider some of the movies I like misogynistic.
Many of the posters here do not like Feig’s films, but his films continue to be financially successful. That’s no measure of quality, but that is a measure of the existence of an audience for his movies, some of whom are presumably repeat business, and some of whom are just taken in by the concept or the trailers.
There are 321 million people living in the US. Say you know a thousand women who aren’t going to see the reboot. So what?
I agree with everything you said, except this…#Gamergate was not “a bunch of misogynists”. Sure there were some, but the issues that got most people engaged in that movement were transparency, honest relationships between game developers and reviewers, and the desire to not have social engineering foisted upon the gaming public by a bunch of “elites”.
If the movement hadn’t been born out of a dude spreading a bunch of lies about his girlfriend – and they have been repeatedly and thoroughly proven to be lies – then I might buy that. Well, and, as a film critic, I’d also have to point out that a lot of what the people involve believe constitutes “ethical” criticism has no bearing on what it means to be a critic in 2015, or what a critic does, period. Reviews are supposed to be opinions, opinions that come out of a specific person from their specific viewpoint. The idea is to convey to the reader why the critic thinks those things and then the reader is free to agree or disagree. We’re all at the mercy of the product providers in a way, but that doesn’t stop me from saying how I actually feel.
That said, this marks the last thing I have to say about GamerGate as this isn’t really the place to discuss it.
Well as far as I’m aware isn’t Zoe Quinn supposed to be a pathological liar? People have been interviewed about her. Apparently she killed a guy in self defense and then bragged she did it. She also got a good review on that game she made because she was seeing a journalist, that’s what started Gamers Gate. Quite right to.
Hey if people want to read about Gamergate, there are tons of websites and sources of info. Let’s just say that with all the changes that have been made in that industry in response to the controversy, it will go down in history as a positive overall.