So what did you guys think of The Dark Knight Rises?

Figured we needed a better thread to discuss this than the other, for obvious reasons. What are your thoughts?

I don’t know if I like it better than The Dark Knight or not.

I am going to watch it again with (hopefully) no kids making noise.

It’s a good movie nonetheless.

I enjoyed it (surprisingly) as I’m not a fan of Nolan’s Batman. Yes, I’m an unashamed Burton/Keaton Batman fan. That said, I’m a fan of Batman foremost… I just prefer the gothic fantasy version of Batman versus Nolan’s gritty “real” version. To each his own though, right?

As far as DK Rises, I really did like the movie even though it was a bitty messy in places. I was shocked to find that I really dug Hathaway as Catwoman (no one can top Pfeiffer though) and Tom Hardy as Bane was fantastic. The majority of folks seem to like it less than Dark Knight, but ultimately, the movie avoids the curse of “sucky 3rd part of a trilogy”… Blade 3 and X-Men 3 it is most certainly not.

Saw it last night, hated it. I was tempted to walk out halfway through. I don’t know what the hell they were thinking but the plot and dialogue were incomprehensible. I kept having the reaction of “wait, seriously?” to stupid plot directions. I never thought they’d make a batman movie worse than Forever but this movie did. It’s mostly because Forever was bad because of over-the-top camp. Rises is just a poorly written and produced movie. I’m glad Nolan is done, at the rate he was going the next movie probably wouldn’t have even had batman in it and Bruce Wanye would have an emo haircut and be a cutter.

My thoughts?

“Some days, you just can’t get rid of a bomb!”

Seriously though…

Banes voice - Goofy.

Plot - Convenient that the bomb is just gonna detonate on its own. Convenient that the reactor has a safety mechanism to flood it. And wait, Batman has a reactor not? What is he, Iron Man? And what was the point of everything after they got it if the plan all along was to allow it to detonate anyway? Why not just detonate it immediately? Or after Batman is thrown in prison so he can watch if that’s what Bane wanted?

I’d also heard some talk show host call bane a fire breather, and I though that was what the mask was for, which would have been cool, but instead he just beat people up. Not much of a supervillian. I mean other than blowing up all that shit. The movie was good up till that point I guess.

I guess I liked the ending. I didn’t expect it. And the Robin twist was good.

Overall I liked it better than the first one. I rewatched that recently and the pacing is so goddamn slow. It was neat the first time because I didn’t know the story but it just wasn’t that enjoyable the second time around.

I enjoyed it. Begins is still my favorite of the series.

I really think Rises was too much packed into one movie. TDK felt that way to a lesser extent; specifically, when everything speeds up and Dent dies. Can’t help but wonder if Ledger had not died, how different Rises would have been.

Being a huge Batman fan, I was a bit disappointed with this new film; it was far from terrible, but could have been better.

The Bad

  • The plot was murky and rushed.

  • Selina Kyle (Catwoman) didn’t really serve much purpose in the story other than being a sidekick towards the end.

  • Bane was pretty tame compared to the Joker and lacked any charisma. Towards the end, we were given some tragic back-story in an attempt to feel bad for him.

  • The clean energy reactor was lifted right of Iron Man. :slight_smile:

  • The “Bat” was a rather clunky vehicle, completely lacking in style.

  • The film was a little too political (Occupy Gotham, anyone?).

  • A good portion of the dialogue (not just Bane) could be difficult to understand at times.

The Good

  • All of the scenes with Alfred were very moving, even if he did depart the story a little early.

  • Although I didn’t care for Bane, the early fight between him and Batman was pretty intense. Seeing our hero broken and unmasked made for a sense of violation (also when Bane breaks into WayneTech).

  • I thought that Blake was going to be a throw-away character, but ended up really liking him. The Robin twist, particularly when he finds the Bat Cave, was a pretty amazing moment.

  • The ending was really good, although it would have been interesting if we didn’t actually see Bruce and Selina (only Alfred’s reaction shot).

Overall, I think that Christopher Nolan and his group have done some really good work with the Batman franchise. While The Dark Knight remains the pinnacle of the series, one can only imagine what Rises could have been if Heath Ledger were still alive…

Its a hollywood movie, of course they have to throw in something “green” that will save the planet from “global warming”… lol

The Nolan brothers and Christopher Nolan are among my favorite movie writers and directors.

I have not seen a bad movie from them.

Overall I really liked it, despite the quick pace. I feel like Blake’s knowledge of Bruce’s secret a bit too convenient. Ah well.

Also, my $0.02 about the Nolan/Burton perspective of Batman:

I feel one actually read the comic and the other just looked at the pictures. There were a lot of references to the comics in this movie including The Dark Knight Returns and Kingdom Come and I thought that was pretty cool.

it was amazing! Period

I, for one, loved it. I saw it twice in IMAX and I’m about to go see it again in an hour. It is not without faults, but highly entertaining IMO.

I loved Bane’s voice, didn’t have a problem with it at all.

See, I hated that. It wouldn’t have been so bad if it wasn’t overly amplified and obviously added in post.

My main issue is that there’s no reason why anyone in the movie does anything. The motivations are hidden or non-existant. Most of the characters seem to be totally superflous and I spent a lot of the movie trying to figure out who the hell everyone was. I kept mixing up the young cop with the toadying businessman’s assistant for the first hour of the film and when Ras’s daughter showed up it took me 5 minutes to realize it was the random enviro-chick that seemed to be pointless from the start of the movie. That should have been some big reveal but it just made everything else that happened up to than pointless as the motivations were all wrong.

I’m still not sure what the hell Bane was trying to do? Win over the downtrodden of the city by releasing all the criminals they’d successfully gotten off the streets then threatening to blow everything up? Huh?

Gah, I can’t even articulate how much I hate this movieevery time I think about it. Please, can someone explain to me why this isn’t utter shit?

I agree that at first I hated the way Bane’s voice was louder than everything.

But that became an integral part of the movie. He’s a villain.

I’m pretty sure Bane’s motivation was to control the city through fear and turn the country on its head at least for a little while. Then to blow the city to kingdom come with Bruce Wayne watching via the 13" tv in the pit.

Pretty sick if you ask me.

After seeing it for the second time I caught was bane was saying. Something along the lines of knowing the bomb was going to go off, and wanted to fill the citizens with false hope, and pretending he was on their side even though he knew everyone was going to die. He was trying to destroy gotham because oscar schindler couldn’t do it in the first movie. (Just noticed this pretty much echos what noslliT said, so I apologize for being repetitive).

Overall I really liked it. I might be a little biased though, because a good chunk of the film was shot around pittsburgh. I thought the reactor was a lot like the plot from Spiderman 2 (doc oc tries to make clean, renewable energy that could potentially destroy the city). It’s also like Iron man/ avengers with the Arc Reactor powering the tesseract (not sure how you spell it). I’m not knocking it as much as just saying that it was something I noticed. But overall I think it was a good way to end the series. I loved the Robin twist (I thought he was going to say his real name was “Grayson” or “Todd” or “Drake” but I feel like there would have been too many people in the theater who wouldn’t have recognized those names). Plus just hearing “Robin” out loud was pretty neat since most people didn’t think there would be any allusion to Robin in the Nolan series).

Exactly, it just reeks of power.

Not sure I can help you with that one, man. I guess because I am familiar with most of the actors it didn’t at all confuse me. That one guy did totally look like William Defoe.

Bane’s end game was simply the total destruction of the city, just like with Ras in the first film, which would then instill a sense of fear in the rest of the world. The rest was just a game to prolong the pain, to show the people [in the city and watching from the rest of the outside world] that their sense of hope is simply false; they have no chance. If you saw Fincher’s version of The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, it isn’t too different from what was said during [victim]'s torture scene about how [killer] received pleasure watching the victims try to talk their way out of it, then to watch that glimmer of hope fade as they realize there is no escape.

I really didn’t find the story too murky. It’s kind of tightly woven, actually. I don’t think you can cut out one scene without cutting out something importaint. Sort of like the theatrical version of Terminator 2, were the next scene is 100% reactionary to the one before it. TDK pretty much was the same way, too.

But the movie is not without faults, of course. I have a big issue with how quickly Batman warms up to Catwoman. I have seen the film three times, and every time I watch her hop into the back of the Bat with Batman I scream inside, “NO WHY ARE YOU TRUSTING HER, SHE IS GOING TO DO SOMETHING WHILE YOUR BACK IS TURNED!” even though I know it doesn’t happen. Of course, this does sort of end up biting him in the ass, when she betrays him to save herself. After that, I’m not so sure I could forgive her and trust her again, yet he does. There needed to be a scene earlier on where we see the good side of Selina, something that Bruce needs to see, but we didn’t really get it.

I loved the movie but I had a few problems with it…

first of all How did Bruce get back to Gotham… All he had was a piece of bread when he left the pit… :slight_smile:

secondly how did he walk across the ice to put the gas for the flame bat signal :slight_smile:

And I loved the line WHERES THE TRIIIIIIIIIIIGGER WHERE IS IT…

OFF TOPIC …If you like Tom Hardy then check out Bronson on netflix