Change my mind… ![]()
This is objectively true.
What do you mean by soundtracks? You mean the pop music played over montages or the score by Randy Edelman?
Because if it’s the score you are referencing the GB2 score has one thing and one thing only going for it: The GB Hero Theme. The rest is standard filler with not real thematic resonance.
Plus GB 1 has..Dana’s Theme. And Venkman’s theme. Plus Gozer’s theme. It’s all really great stuff. Gozer’s theme is beautifully gothic. All extremely memorable and well placed/adjusted. The use of the theremin is amazing and so iconic.
Ghostbusters 1 is a MUCH better score. Is a great listen even outside of the film. Ghostbusters 2 isn’t much of a listen outside of the film. It works and is functional for the film, but it’s basic in ways the first film never was. Some of the score sounds like bad sitcom music from the ‘90s.
But that theme is really something else. Part of me hopes the GB2 Edelman theme will be quoted in GB:A. I very much doubt it will but I would LOVE for it to happen since it represents the best theme of the actual GB team.
That being said…Elmer Bernstein wipes the floor with Edelman.
To be clear, I said soundtrack, not score. Two completely different music selections. Also, I believe your theremin reference is actually an ondes martenot.
I totally love both soundtracks, but I would give a slight edge to GB1. Bernstein composed a better score, but I still love the GB2 score as well, especially the hero theme and the love theme. As for the pop songs, they’re all great. My favorite tracks on GB1 are Hot Night and Savin’ the Day, and on GB2, On Our Own and Flip City. I probably listen to the GB2 soundtrack more often, but that’s mainly because I still have my audio tape copy which I often play in my car (I wore out my GB1 tapes years ago and should probably replace them).
That’s right you did say soundtrack. But both are technically the soundtrack. That’s why I asked which one you were referring to. That’s interesting that it’s not a theremin that was used. I guess I always just assumed that’s what it was. But there ya go, you learn something new everyday.
I still think GB1 has the edge over GB2 for the songs, specially with how they are used in the films themselves. The GB2 soundtrack has On Our Own, which is great. But the original soundtrack is maybe on of the best soundtracks ever. I mean come on. Savin The Day? Cleaning Up The Town? Lest we not forget the actual Ray Parker Jr theme song.
GB2 is good. GB1 is great.
But when you look at how the songs are placed in the actual films? Very few things get me pumped up like hearing Saving The Day after Venkman yells “Come on! Let’s run some red lights!”. It’s Billy Jean-esq. Then we’ve got the rocking big band almost swing style sound of “Cleaning Up the Town” by Bus Boys. It always surprised me these two songs, Saving the Day and Cleaning Up The Town, weren’t major hits. Just great songs. Cleaning Up The Town sounds like it could’ve been made in 1954. It’s timeless.
Then you’ve got “Magic”..which by itself isn’t my favourite song in the world but the way it’s used…it just works. Especially the skyline shot and the energy beams forming up against the Manhattan skyline. Just a beautiful shot that holds for just the right amount of time.
We can all agree that Elmer Bernstein’s score is better than Danny Edelman’s. But Cleanin’ Up The Town, Magic, and Saving The Day don’t hold a candle to Run DMC’s Ghostbusters, On Our Own, and Higher and Higher. All those songs just stir my soul, the others…they’re just good songs.
looking at people who think the GB2 soundtrack is better
“Don’t look at me. I think these people are completely nuts.”
Well that’s why they call them opinions I guess. I mean technically you can’t be wrong…
I mean Run DMC’s version isn’t better than the original. All the songs you listed are good songs from GB2. But GB2 has some pretty Meh songs. I like Danny Elfman, but Oingo Boingo aren’t really my jam. Then there’s…what’s the title? “We’re Back”? that has maybe the worst chorus of any song ever lol. It sounds like clown or carnival music
Plus I’ve never been a fan of “rap the plot” songs. “Spirit” and “Flip City” aren’t the best
But yeah. If it stirs your soul? Turn that shit up and rock out with your PKE meter out. All the power to you.
Both are very good soundtracks, but I would give a definite edge to Ghostbusters II because, overall as an album, it’s more cohesive.
[quote=RichardLess post_id=4938029 time=1597025335 user_id=47215]Then there’s…what’s the title? “We’re Back”? that has maybe the worst chorus of any song ever lol. It sounds like clown or carnival music
[/quote]
I agree it has a carnival vibe, but I love that song. Always reminded me of the theme to Aero the Acrobat:
[youtube=OuytyUvv2pk][/youtube]
GB2 felt the need to use rap music as that was what was in the zeitgeist of the late 80’s.
I felt it was an unnecessary add on to the franchise.
The original soundtrack tried to feature some of the hottest artists on the Arista label in 1984. It only made sense that II would feature some of the hottest artists on MCA in 1988/1989, also including Doug E. Fresh’s epic track. All of those are worthwhile singles if you like vinyl.
I listened to both soundtracks for years. I even brought them to work and played them over the restaurant sound system. Didn’t bother anyone, just a small bento place on the strip.
Regarding the scores, both are great but I prefer the heroic and spooky aspects of GB2. When the boys notice the Statue of Liberty on the Ectomobile’s licence plate is uplifting. Battling the Scoleri Brothers is epic. The rising danger in the darkroom. I can’t say enough good stuff about that music. I know some say it’s generic but I disagree. I’m more than happy we’re finally getting an official release next year.
The Ghostbusters soundtrack I bought doesn’t have Gozer’s theme. Or the library theme. Actually it does have Dana’s theme but that’s it. It only has the music with singing mostly. Unless there is a 2nd soundtrack for the instrumental music? Come to think of it the same can be said for my Ghostbusters 2 soundtrack.
I always liked the use of Run DMC. One legit New York institution representing for another.
Many films have two soundtracks: the commercial music release (the most common), and the theatrical soundtrack (the score music conducted by the orchestra, which often used to be rarer). The soundtrack you’re referring to is the commercial release.
Honestly, the hip-hop inspired GB2 tracks still hold up pretty well. On Our Own still gets radio play.
On the topic of On Our Own, here’s a pretty decent cover by Youtube singer J-Mi:
I recall a review of GB2 from the summer it came out, which said something very similar.
Alex