If by detractor you mean toxic scum lords on the internet with nothing better to do that comment on someone’s weight, definitely. But if by detractor you mean anyone that has legitimate criticisms or doesn’t like the reboot for normal reasons. Not quite.
Sets up that they’re referring specifically to the toxic comments.
Having already set up that they’re referring to the toxic comments, the ad-libbing in question is being used as a way for the cast to respond to the toxic fervent backlash from their toxic critics. I expect some quips about gender or weight.
Disproportional because the people with actual concerns and legitimate criticisms are being overpowered by the overwhelming toxic negativity, lumping them together, and making it appear that there are only two camps: pro-reboot and anti-reboot. There are plenty of people not for the reboot but that doesn’t erupt horrid remarks.
While the article is clearly in favor of the reboot (I fully give you that chip) at no point does it act like all Ghostbusters fans are awful or that the cast is going after us all. It’s made very clear that the detractors that they’re responding to are the ones that are spewing hatred. The only way I can see someone being offended by this is if they themselves are one of the toxic people being targeted.
I hardly know anything about anatomy, so correct me if I’m wrong, but is it just me or do movies not have middle fingers?
Actually last I checked they didn’t have any fingers, or cells, or organs, and came either as a celluloid film print or on a digital hard drive. I guess I have to refresh my knowledge of the medium.
With everything that’s has been leaked and complained about towards this film I’m at the point that I just don’t care anymore. It is what it is. Good or bad. I honestly don’t care anymore. Am I going to go see it? Not sure yet. Me and my group have been asked to come to our local theatre to kinda help get the ppl excited for it. Plus they are giving us free tickets to see it so either way I’m not spending money to go see it. Now I’m not a supporter of this film but others in my group are tickled pink to see it. The way I see it is what’s the point of bitching about a movie? It’s not gonna effect my day to day life style. It’s a movie. Your either gonna like it, think it was an ok or so so movie or your gonna say it was a bad movie. Are people going to riot in the streets after the movie? I sure hope not but from the sounds of some people on the internet you would almost think it could possibly happen.
Thing is, fans don’t know what they want until they get it. It’s the job of people like Paul Feig to work out what fans need rather than what the vocal ones insist they want.
So this post pretty much one of the ongoing problems we have as a community, and that some posters have already touched upon: an inability to differentiate between a remark, condemnation or verbal attack on a select minority of a community and one intended to target the whole community.
And I was reluctant to say this earlier, although j10kmm did sorta hint at it earlier: if you’re feeling that the scene in question is targeting you, the two most likely reasons are:
You’re part of the problem crowd that inspired it in the first place.
Or you’re maybe being a bit over-sensitive and letting something not actually aimed at you get to you.
Well, in all fairness, couldn’t the same be said about a scene like that being included in the film? Overly sensitive people who make millions of dollars to play pretend for a living?
It could be, though in the case of the fans who’ve been the most critical of the response by Feig, McCarthy and Jones have at most had to endure less than a dozen remarks that were aimed either specifically at them, or the fans interpreted/assumed were aimed at them.
Feig and his cast in contrast have had to endure dozens, if not closer to tens of dozens (if not higher) insults, remarks and hate posts for months on end. I can’t say I’d not resort to putting a scene into a film I was making as way of burning off some of that frustration, and ■■■■■■■ off a movie director or his cast is one of the worst things you can do, because they have a way of easily making you look like a putz to millions across the country, especially when you genuinely have been an inhuman ■■■■■■■.
Oh I DEFINATELY knew what I wanted in a new GB movie. Feig’s pile of trash ain’t it. A sexist film with TOTAL gender swapping ain’t it. Seeing vulgar responses from the director, head of Sony, and cast, including now commentary IN THE MOVIE ain’t it. And while my attitude is not as severe as that of the trolls, I have to stand with them, as at the end of the day they ARE fans, maybe just frustrated past the breaking point by the ■■■■ of something they identified with, enjoyed or in some way held dear which has remained untouched and constant for all these years (I’m not talking expanded universe that maybe 5% of fans are aware of).
It’s really baffling me how extremely personal people take remarks not aimed at them just to have a reason to be angry at a director for making a movie they don’t agree with.
Also, if you don’t want to be called an idiot or ■■■■■■■, don’t act like one.
I’ve encountered some of those “fans.” No, you do not have to defend them. And no, they were not pushed passed any breaking point. They are simply jerks, always have been, always will be. You want to talk about ■■■■? Go look up a news story on the Middle East or something. Not a freakin movie. And not some imaginary expanded universe. Good God…
Why would anyone want to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with some of the worst this community has to offer just because we share the same fandom and interests?
To take that line of thinking to it’s extreme, it’d be like someone suggesting that reasonable Christians should stand beside the Westboro Baptist Church and support them because they both had the same base religion, or that we should support Micah Johnson after he murdered 5 Police officers in Dallas yesterday, just because we’re reaching our wits’ end over people dying in Police custody or during arrests.
We should not feel any obligation to defend and/or excuse the trolls in our community just because they watched the same movie we did, and love the same no-ghost logo we do. You bring the community into disrepute? You’re no fan to me, nor one I want to know.
Another example of going over the top in lodging your dislike of the film. Please don’t trivialise ■■■■ to provide a catchy remark, because this film doesn’t even enter the same universe as an actual case of physical ■■■■.