Ai written containment unit manual

Yeah, I think there’s a huge gap in what’s being discussed here. Technical grunt work AI vs. generative AI. Also, I have zero idea what I’m talking about.

To me, generative AI is like a nasty combination of Photoshop and Google Search, meshing together existing stuff rather than creating anything new. Not unlike the modern entertainment industry, really.

Just because you can doesn’t mean you should.

We got a new Beatles song in the 90s without any AI. It’s really not The Beatles, though. Not in my eyes. Let It Be was the last record, there’s no changing that. Development stuff exists, and it’s cool to experience. That stuff doesn’t have to be finished out just to have new material, though. I don’t want to see an AI GHOSTBUSTERS: HELLBENT, either.

Low effort AI slop detected: dislike deployed

you sound like the average redditor.

This song was suppose to be part of that 1990s release. The song wasn’t done flippantly. And if you look into the how and the why this was done you’d understand the production issues they had in the 1990s. It was on the same tapes as the other songs but it had mastering problems the other songs did not have. Which is why A.I. was required. In fact many Beatles fans are hoping they go back and use this process to clean the other 1990s songs such as “Free as Bird” which has some quality issues from a sound perspective. But this new song “Now and then” was worked on in the 1990s, which is how they got George Harrison on the track. But they couldn’t get John’s vocals free and seperate from the piano. So they threw in the towel and gave up. Finally technology had an answer for how this could be done.

And I don’t buy into this “just because you can doesn’t mean you should”. Do you know how much joy that song brought people. It was poignant and beautiful. And it sounded like a lost Beatles track.

You can debate whether it’s a Beatles song or not, I think it is since the surviving members and family members all consented. It featured all the Beatles. John apparently wrote it “for Paul”(that was the note on the tapes). And I have no doubt in my mind that had he lived The Beatles would’ve reunited. Was it written AS a Beatles song? No. Was it recorded as one? Heck yeah. If the argument that John did not record with the other Beatles present and thus that makes it not a Beatles song, there were many Beatles song created and written by some members of the band without input from the others.

But beyond the Beatles. I’d like you & the others here to check this out. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOw6gO8rEiU

That was created by generative AI, and it created a new a very funny thing.

Generative AI has uses. Comedy is one of them. The comedy is derived from the ridiculous and audacious nature of AI. AI is the joke. What’s that old Marshall McLuhan quote? The medium is the message?

There is a YouTuber who uses A.I. to create sometimes hilarious and often horrific videos. This one on cats is legitimately funny. His channel is full of content like this.

You brought up “just because you can doesn’t mean you should”. So Here’s one on Jurassic Park that made me chuckle.

As Sassy Steve Rogers once said, “No, I don’t think I will.”

Memes are also hilarious while being low effort.

I’m reminded of an Ernie Kovacs quote, something like “Television: a medium. So called because it is neither rare nor well done.”

Everyone’s channel is full of content like this. That’s the problem. It was funny the first few times, but it’s getting old quick.

Great tech tool, lazy creativity.

The computer is a tool and the individual applied scientist needs to interpret results as well as exactly what they asked the computer to do and how. The perfect application is repetitive complex calculations, however the user needs to determine the equations, and should be able to recognize erroneous results by simple inspection. If one doesn’t understand the basic concepts, one cannot possibly understand the results the computer is generating. Garbage in = Garbage out.

I don’t know if “applied scientist” is the best descriptor for someone generating AI fan art. Hell, I don’t even think “artist” applies all that well.

“I” sound like a Redditor? Have you been over there? The Reddit hive mind is all over the fear of AI wagon. YOU and Kingpin sound like Redditors/twitter users!

Also the Luddites feared new technology because it impacted their livelihood in the short term. Kingpin wrote an essay on how AI was scary because job loss! Hence he literally sounds like a Luddite!

1 Like

I wrote a couple of paragraphs.

If you think a couple of paragraphs constitutes an essay, then I’d hate to see what would constitute a dissertation or thesis. :sigh:

I think Ed was using it for the examples of A.I.'s use in scientific/engineering projects.

It’s called sarcasm.

1 Like

AI is literally causing people to lose their jobs in my industry as we speak. I won’t lie, I’ve fiddled around with it because it’s the hot new thing, who doesn’t want to play with the new toy? But it should never be used as a replacement, which everyone in power seemingly wants. To paraphrase, I want AI to do my laundry so I can write, not write so I can do my laundry.

Everyone’s channel is full of content like this?

Hmm. I don’t think that’s true. You say It’s getting “old”? So what you are saying is AI was funny when it was new? and now it’s..not? Seems like this is less about the merits of something and more about its “newness” or if it’s a “fad”. The fact that you thought it produced a comical effect at all is the point here. Not how many times. And it seems based on your reticence to engage with AI generated material that you are using less of a logic based approach to this and more an emotional one(which is fine and no less valid but it’s important to draw a distinction between the two)

About the recurrent theme of “effort”. I don’t know when this became an “effort” based quantifier but let us think about what that means. Humor is often an emotional reaction. Right? Like a Reflex. A bad joke or movie that took a lot of “effort” isn’t any better from the effort it took. You can appreciate the effort for the efforts sake but this delineation between “low effort” and “lots of effort” is not really what this is about. At least not as far as I’m concerned.

Yes AI generated content is low effort. Yes memes are low effort.

But so what? That means they have nothing to offer? Let us remember that AI isn’t generating this material by itself. A person is prompting these results. Perhaps that’ll open up an entire new arena of art. The “prompt”. Where it’s less what the AI produces but how it was driven to that result. Or not? Who knows.

And that’s kind of the point here. So many of you are turning up your noses at this new thing when we don’t even know what we don’t know.

I guess where one sees A.I taking us says something about who we are and how we see the human race. Jobs is a big thing everyone is terrified of. Which makes sense. Automation isn’t new. But do we really see humans becoming obsolete from AI?

And where art is concerned I just don’t think the sky will fall. When synth music became a thing did orchestra cease to exist? No. It became a new aesthetic. It changed things for sure. That’s where I personally see A.I. headed.

You can use a washing machine to do the dishes or do them yourself. One takes more effort. One is automated.

AI is a great tech tool. It’s a tool period. With a lot of potential.

It certainly has the potential to be used for the wrong things. While I don’t trust companies to not use them for these wrong things I do trust people to reject the companies who do. I hope that will be the arbiter of all this in the end.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]Let us remember that AI isn’t generating this material by itself.
[/quote]

Indeed. Most of the generating programs out there are generating content from having been trained on/scanned other people’s work, without their permission/knowledge.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]A person is prompting these results. Perhaps that’ll open up an entire new arena of art.
[/quote]

I think that’s reaching. It’s typing a collection of words into a generating engine, and adding or subtracting ones occasionally as the prompt writer refines the parameters of the images they’re generating. That doesn’t strike me as artistic, that feels more in the realm of coding, or applying meta tags.

Writing prompts to generate an image is not the same as picking up a pencil, a paintbrush, a digital stylus, or even using the humble computer mouse.

I’d argue we don’t need to know every nut and bolt of a thing to know it’s a negative/lazy/regressive thing. I don’t need to plagerize the works of famous writers to know that it would get my reputation trashed and potentially expose me to legal trouble, likewise I don’t need to stick my hand into a bunch of moving gears to know it’d badly injure me and hurt like hell.

I may not know every in and out of A.I.-generating programs and the culture surrounding them, but I believe we’ve seen enough to know it’s a more detrimental force because a lot of people use it for detrimental reasons.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]But do we really see humans becoming obsolete from AI?
[/quote]

I and others can, because we’ve been reading accounts from people who’ve been losing out on work because companies are replacing hired artists with A.I.

A poetry event my workplace was asked to advertise used A.I. artwork for its poster instead of using an actual artist to create it, which seems especially tacky given the poetry event itself was encouraging people to create their own submissions.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]AI is a great tech tool. It’s a tool period. With a lot of potential.
[/quote]

It’s become a culture, and not one I think is good for humanity as a whole.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]It certainly has the potential to be used for the wrong things.
[/quote]

It isn’t just the potential, it has been used to create deep fakes of London’s mayor Sadiq Khan, Joe Biden, Volodymyr Zelenskyy and even Trump. And the additional danger beyond the initial fakery is the fact that not everyone has the critical skills or is smart enough to know those deepfakes are fakes.

I spent seven months walking a picket line against this AI garbage. There is no argument to be made, this isn’t a matter of people not wanting to accept a new technology. Let’s be real, none of this is even truly artificial intelligence. It is regurgitative ■■■■ that can only produce based on theft.

AI lets the talentless feel talented.

You’re going to lose that battle, but I think you know that. Again you folks are Luddites, your literally afraid AI will put you out if work. Only instead of coming for craftsmen and blue collar workers this time technology is comming it’s coming for white collar workers. Boo hoo get over it. Or to put it another way evolve or be left behind.

3 Likes

I’d kindly ask you to stop referring to people who don’t agree with you as “Luddites”, Bison. It’s possible to have this discussion without continually resorting to personal insults.

More examples of the problems rising from the use of A.I., Apple’s A.I.-generated news service posted two invented stories recently:

Apple AI alert falsely claimed Luke Littler had already won darts final

Apple’s AI FALSE news: “Luke Littler wins PDC” and “Rafael Nadal is gay”

In the case of Luke Littler, it announced he’d won a darts tournament before the event had taken place. With tennis player Raphael Nadal, it concocted a story where he’d come out as gay (he’s made no such announcement).

Those two instances may be innocuous in the wider picture, but if the program is inventing stories on small stuff, it carries the danger of inventing stories for the big stuff.

I’m using it academically! I’m refering to the actually historical movement from the 19th century. Why are you uncomfortable with that label? Ah should I call you a 19 century weaver? Frankly what discussion are we having? Someone says AI is a tool, then you post neatly exactly the same thing in response that boils down to AI scares me and is bad! Look at these sensationalist news articles! Ad infinitum.

2 Likes

Your using “Luddites” “academically” feels like a smokescreen to sneakily use it personally. Suffice it to say this isn’t the 19th century, and the people you’ve been branding as “Luddites” use computers, cell phones, the internet, and all sorts of other technological marvels in their daily lives… You’d have more justification in calling the people you disagree with that if we were calling for the abandonment of all technology, but we aren’t.

It doesn’t matter if you don’t like those news articles, they’re reporting the facts of what happened. Even when used innocuously, A.I.-generated content is still producing unpredictable and unreliable results. A.I. is no substitute for actual human reporters, nor is it a substitue for human artists.

Bison, I feel sorry for you. It must feel good to be so ahead of the curve and have so little empathy for human beings. You’re clearly an intelligent person, so I ask you to think about it like this…it has less to do with replacement and more to do with the continued devaluation of all forms of labor in this country.

I am not afraid AI is a better writer than I am, I know it isn’t. What I am afraid of is public acceptance of a shoddy technology that is literally built on stealing work from thousands of real people in service of letting executives pay less for the shows and movies they produce. They do not want us to evolve, they want to cut us out to make a quick buck. If you can’t see the difference, you’re a pretty lousy human being.

First of all copy right and trademarks have gotten our of control thanks to the likes of Disney. Works shouldn’t be under copyright for a 100 years. I grew up with science fiction like TNG. I see chatgpt as an early form of what the fictional enterprise computer or Data could do.

But I’m no ■■■■, I know AI won’t usher in a utopian age. No it’ll become another tool used to increase corporate profits. Lower class workers have been facing redundancy from improvements in technology since the 19th century. Look at something Ghostbusters related; when the real Ghostbusters was made in the 80s they had Japanese women(?) hand color the animation cells, now that’s done by computers. With AI, now technology is coming for a white collar jobs, people who thought technology could never be able do their jobs and it freaks them out.

Side note I’m a pessimist, I know the world’s shit, things getting worse doesn’t bother me.

1 Like