[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]Let us remember that AI isn’t generating this material by itself.
[/quote]
Indeed. Most of the generating programs out there are generating content from having been trained on/scanned other people’s work, without their permission/knowledge.
[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]A person is prompting these results. Perhaps that’ll open up an entire new arena of art.
[/quote]
I think that’s reaching. It’s typing a collection of words into a generating engine, and adding or subtracting ones occasionally as the prompt writer refines the parameters of the images they’re generating. That doesn’t strike me as artistic, that feels more in the realm of coding, or applying meta tags.
Writing prompts to generate an image is not the same as picking up a pencil, a paintbrush, a digital stylus, or even using the humble computer mouse.
I’d argue we don’t need to know every nut and bolt of a thing to know it’s a negative/lazy/regressive thing. I don’t need to plagerize the works of famous writers to know that it would get my reputation trashed and potentially expose me to legal trouble, likewise I don’t need to stick my hand into a bunch of moving gears to know it’d badly injure me and hurt like hell.
I may not know every in and out of A.I.-generating programs and the culture surrounding them, but I believe we’ve seen enough to know it’s a more detrimental force because a lot of people use it for detrimental reasons.
[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]But do we really see humans becoming obsolete from AI?
[/quote]
I and others can, because we’ve been reading accounts from people who’ve been losing out on work because companies are replacing hired artists with A.I.
A poetry event my workplace was asked to advertise used A.I. artwork for its poster instead of using an actual artist to create it, which seems especially tacky given the poetry event itself was encouraging people to create their own submissions.
[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]AI is a great tech tool. It’s a tool period. With a lot of potential.
[/quote]
It’s become a culture, and not one I think is good for humanity as a whole.
[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]It certainly has the potential to be used for the wrong things.
[/quote]
It isn’t just the potential, it has been used to create deep fakes of London’s mayor Sadiq Khan, Joe Biden, Volodymyr Zelenskyy and even Trump. And the additional danger beyond the initial fakery is the fact that not everyone has the critical skills or is smart enough to know those deepfakes are fakes.