Ai written containment unit manual

I’m not sure what the nationality and gender of BOSS Films animators has to do with anything, but it’s funny— all of this arguing for AI and you don’t do us the favor of using it to shorten your massive posts. That’s where the tech really shines. :love:

Indeed. Most of the generating programs out there are generating content from having been trained on/scanned other people’s work, without their permission/knowledge.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]A person is prompting these results. Perhaps that’ll open up an entire new arena of art.
[/quote]

I think that’s reaching. It’s typing a collection of words into a generating engine, and adding or subtracting ones occasionally as the prompt writer refines the parameters of the images they’re generating. That doesn’t strike me as artistic, that feels more in the realm of coding, or applying meta tags.

Writing prompts to generate an image is not the same as picking up a pencil, a paintbrush, a digital stylus, or even using the humble computer mouse.

I’d argue we don’t need to know every nut and bolt of a thing to know it’s a negative/lazy/regressive thing. I don’t need to plagerize the works of famous writers to know that it would get my reputation trashed and potentially expose me to legal trouble, likewise I don’t need to stick my hand into a bunch of moving gears to know it’d badly injure me and hurt like hell.

I may not know every in and out of A.I.-generating programs and the culture surrounding them, but I believe we’ve seen enough to know it’s a more detrimental force because a lot of people use it for detrimental reasons.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]But do we really see humans becoming obsolete from AI?
[/quote]

I and others can, because we’ve been reading accounts from people who’ve been losing out on work because companies are replacing hired artists with A.I.

A poetry event my workplace was asked to advertise used A.I. artwork for its poster instead of using an actual artist to create it, which seems especially tacky given the poetry event itself was encouraging people to create their own submissions.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]AI is a great tech tool. It’s a tool period. With a lot of potential.
[/quote]

It’s become a culture, and not one I think is good for humanity as a whole.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002712 time=1735973627 user_id=44443]It certainly has the potential to be used for the wrong things.
[/quote]

It isn’t just the potential, it has been used to create deep fakes of London’s mayor Sadiq Khan, Joe Biden, Volodymyr Zelenskyy and even Trump. And the additional danger beyond the initial fakery is the fact that not everyone has the critical skills or is smart enough to know those deepfakes are fakes.

[/quote]

Just a quick little aside. I have to bring this up. You have this habit of quoting a part of a response while leaving out important bits. Why do you do that? For the prompt thing I clearly say “Or not. Who knows” yet you don’t include that. You stopped just short of that little important piece of context. You do this quite consistently. Leaving out the part where I acknowledge “hey maybe I’m wrong” and then quoting me and telling me why I could be wrong yet not including that part just seems..I don’t know. I’ve noticed it’s a pattern with you though. Every time I’m like “Why does he do that?”. Sorry I know it’s off topic but I’ve seen you do this so many times I had to ask.

No. You are right. It isn’t the same.

The point I’m making with the writing prompt thing is that this is such a new “thing” we don’t know how it will develop. I have seen and posted here, very funny AI created material. Now it’s funny BECAUSE it’s AI. The potential “art” I’m talking about is maybe in that, perhaps, the IDEA behind the prompt IS the art. Yes that’s reaching. I mean of course it is. Had I told you 15 years ago NFT’s would be a thing you’d say “that’s reaching” because no one knows how a thing will develop. I don’t know. You don’t know. That’s the point.

In your view is photoshop detrimental? Avid editing? These things have been used to ■■■■ people. To make them think something that isn’t true.

I can take a clip of a President giving a 2 hour speech and edit it in a way that makes him look like he’s saying something he didn’t. I can use photoshop to make that president appear in compromising situations.

How is this any different? You are saying something is detrimental because of its chances to ■■■■ people into believing something that isn’t true.

This is not a unique Ai thing. This has been done throughout history. Again we are villainizing a tool instead of those who misuse it.

Care to expand on this? It’s become a culture? I find that interesting. What do you mean by this?

Deep fakes have also been used in film and TV shows to positive results. But yes you’ve hit a real problem. Not everyone has the critical thinking skills or is “smart” enough to recognize this. But again. That’s a media literacy problem. Many don’t know when a newspaper is being biased. Or when a TV news outlet is presenting one side of a story. So that’s an education issue where we need to make sure people have the tools and the education to know how to spot these sorts of things. That comes with time.

Here’s something I was thinking about. You used the term detrimental. There are numerous inventions throughout time that have been detrimental to humankind but still play a positive role in society. Look at cars. Poisoning our environment. Killing our planet. They kill MILLIONS every year directly thru accidents. Or indirectly thru cancer of toxic fumes. Now I’m not saying cars and AI are the same but I am saying this “detrimental” label requires balance.

I started out by saying maybe I have a different outlook on AI because I have seen its positive impact in person. A real tangible result. So while it suck’s a technology will always ultimately get used for nefarious purposes, a daughter hearing her father’s voice? That’s beautiful.

Should people like Dr.D fight like hell to make sure their union contracts include safety precautions so the impacts on jobs will be as minimal as possible? Yes. 100%. But to say there’s no argument? There’s no nuance? Again maybe it’s because my own experience with AI was so positive and emotional but I read things like that and just think “fear. This all based on fear”. And people tend not to make the best choices when fear plays a part in thinking.

So far I haven’t seen generative AI create any new problems that didn’t exist beforehand. Fake celebrity endorsements? Not New. Making it seem like someone is saying or doing something they didn’t? Not new.

This isn’t an AI problem ladies and gents. It’s a people problem.

1 Like

NFTs are a scam/money laundering.

Apologies in advance, this one is going to be more of an essay. :stuck_out_tongue:

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]Just a quick little aside. I have to bring this up. You have this habit of quoting a part of a response while leaving out important bits. Why do you do that?
[/quote]

I think primarily it’s because I just want to focus on the main points I’m responding to. There are also instances where I don’t think I can provide a sufficient counter-argument to something someone has written, so I don’t quote that section. Likewise there are instances where I have no interest in responding to a particular section of a post (either because I think someone else in the topic has already provided a better response than I ever could, or because I think the hypothetical idea being presented doesn’t merit my time and effort).

It’s not that I’m trying to present selected quotes in order to take them out of context, I just have no desire to double the length of the post I’m writing by including everything someone else had written. If a user wishes to see all the bits you’d written, then can scroll back up the topic to see your full post.

And I think your post asking me why I write my posts this way proves my point… Before even asking your question, you’d quoted my entire previous post, along with the sections of your previous post I’d embedded, creating a massive body of quoted text that doesn’t even really serve the purpose to your question.

It’s not intentionally malicious, I guess it’s just the habit I’ve fallen into.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]The point I’m making with the writing prompt thing is that this is such a new “thing” we don’t know how it will develop.
[/quote]

It may be relatively new, but we have already seen glimpses of how it’s developing:

•Art websites like DeviantArt (if not being filled) with A.I.-generated art, then certainly being choked with lots of “insta-art”* content, much of which bears the same plasticy feel that a lot of A.I.-generated artwork has. On top of this, submissions of non A.I.-generated art end up getting buried under the deluge of generated work.

And moving away from the writing-prompt side of things:

•A.I. News services (most prominently in this case Apple’s) generating completely false stories.

•A.I. Being used to fake statements and photos of world leaders and politicians in order to stir up local or more widespread hatred. In the case of the Mayor of London I previously mentioned, someone used samples of his voice, fed through an A.I. program to make it sound like he’d disparaged the Armistice Day commemorations that are held in the U.K. in November, and that he’d called for there to be pro-Palestinian marches on the day instead. After the clip went public, it was circulated by far-right groups, which led to a spike in hate speech aimed towards him.

-In Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s case, it was used to map his face onto the movements of an actor’s, in a video which was intended to present the illusion that Zelenskyy was urging the people of Ukraine to surrender.

-And a further example, a high school principal in Baltimore had his life turned upside down and reputation tarnished when an audio clip supposedly of him making racist remarks was posted online. It was later revealed that the audio clip had been made by the school’s athletics director, who had used the school’s computers to create the fake audio clip with A.I. tools. The athletics director’s motive appeared to be to discredit the principal, as the athletics director was being investigated over the theft of $1,916 from the school.

-LINK

I’m not saying A.I. will grow to become something like Skynet in the Terminator films, but I believe it presents a risk of producing art and other creative endeavours in the same vein as fast food: quick, cheap, and cheerful… But ultimately made without heart and, in the long-term, not healthy for us. :whatever:

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]I have seen and posted here, very funny AI created material. Now it’s funny BECAUSE it’s AI.
[/quote]

While these “film ruined by A.I.” videos did produce a bit of a chuckle from me, once that chuckle had subsided, and I reflected on the videos, I was left with my concern over how convincing some bits of them are. While there are sections that are glaringly fake… And I’d hope people of most ages would be able to spot that they are fake, there are bits (like when Kate Winslet brings out and drinks that bottle, or when Billy Zane eats The Heart of the Ocean) that show the line is getting blurred, and that someone with less humoristic intent can use them for nefarious purposes.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]Had I told you 15 years ago NFT’s would be a thing you’d say “that’s reaching” because no one knows how a thing will develop. I don’t know. You don’t know. That’s the point.
[/quote]

I probably would’ve said that, yeah. :slight_smile:

And on the topic of NFTs, it’s my hope that as we hear so little about them these days, it’s a sign that the NFT fad has faded, and that hopefully A.I. art will eventually die the same death.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]In your view is photoshop detrimental? Avid editing? These things have been used to ■■■■ people. To make them think something that isn’t true.
[/quote]

I don’t view Photoshop or Avid editing as intrinsically detrimental (though Photoshop itself is now advertising A.I. features). You’re correct that they have been used for fakery in their own right (and if we go down the years, photographs and celluloid film have been used for all sorts of fakery from the Loch Ness Monster to Georges Méliès).

The difference between those programs and A.I.-generators in being used to create fakery, is that A.I.-programs can generate images, video files and sound clips almost instantly. With Photoshop or Avid it may still take days to get a decent fake ready, with A.I. you might be able to get it ready in time for that day, or the following day’s news cycle.

A brief aside, in relation to creating digital art; Photoshop requires skill and time to create decent, greate, or exceptional works. I wouldn’t trade any of those hours I’ve spent in Photoshop and Illustrator over the years because in the end, I either achieved the piece I was after… Or I assembled something that was very close to what I was after.

An A.I. art generator might be able to give be a loose approximation of the idea I had in my head, but the combination of my pencil, my mouse, Illustrator and Photoshop is what gets me the exact piece of artwork I actually wanted. :slight_smile:

And if I didn’t have the skills to achieve it myself, there would be artists out there who’d be happy to take my commission. :wink:

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]Again we are villainizing a tool instead of those who misuse it.
[/quote]

Some tools earn their negative reputations, and some tools earn their regulation. A.I. may be a slave to the whims of the people who use it, but it still provides an opportunity and a space for people to instantly, or near-instantly, create harmful or misleading content.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]Care to expand on this? It’s become a culture? I find that interesting. What do you mean by this?
[/quote]

A culture of people who are happy to accept the low-effort products of A.I.-generated content because it’s been wrapped up as something that’s cheaper or convenient (see the “fast food insta-art” bit I wrote earlier), a culture where the efforts of actual artists and writers are devalued becuase people with no creative talent can flood creative spaces with their generated content.

It’s a culture that, if suitably ■■■■■■ off and vindictive, can result in spurned employees, lovers or schoolyard bullies creating compromising video and audio files of innocent people… All with the comfort and convenience of their office or school library computers.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]But again. That’s a media literacy problem.
[/quote]

I don’t think it’s just an issue of media literacy. Education definitely plays a part in the problem, but there’s also a person’s intellectual level… Their gullibility level… And some people want to believe the fakes no, matter what evidence is presented to the contrary.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]So while it suck’s a technology will always ultimately get used for nefarious purposes, a daughter hearing her father’s voice? That’s beautiful.
[/quote]

It is beautiful, which is why I advocate that A.I. programs should be subject to regulation.

A.I. voice generators should only be available for purposes like restoring a person’s voice that they’ve lost due to accident or health reasons. It shouldn’t be out there on the internet for any Tom, Dick, or Harry to use for whatever reason they might come up with on a Friday night after a bunch of beers. :whatever:

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]Should people like Dr.D fight like hell to make sure their union contracts include safety precautions so the impacts on jobs will be as minimal as possible? Yes. 100%. But to say there’s no argument? There’s no nuance? Again maybe it’s because my own experience with AI was so positive and emotional but I read things like that and just think “fear. This all based on fear”. And people tend not to make the best choices when fear plays a part in thinking.
[/quote]

That seems a bit of an unfair suggestion to make. They didn’t strike because they’d suddenly given into fear, or a fear-influenced line of reasoning. A lot of their decisions would’ve been based on the track record of every major studio in Hollywood over the decades, and the track record they all have in looking to exploit people.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]So far I haven’t seen generative AI create any new problems that didn’t exist beforehand. Fake celebrity endorsements? Not New. Making it seem like someone is saying or doing something they didn’t? Not new.
[/quote]

It hasn’t created anything new yet (which, frankly, is A.I.-generated content largely in a nutshell), but it can make the old problems worse, or easier to achieve.

It can also be used for reading comprehension! Real Ghostbusters wasn’t animated by BOSS films. Which might explain why you didn’t understand the point Bison was getting at. Ink and paint in animation was traditionally done by women( sexism at work). And RGB was animated in many different countries, including Japan. That’s what I believe he was getting at.

(Let me apologize in advance. That “reading comprehension” bit was rude of me but you left yourself open with the “massive post” dig and as someone who also has written massive posts I felt the need to return some of that snark your way. But usually you’re a really pleasant and nice person, you’ve done alot for this fanbase, so I feel bad. I meant that in the nicest way possible. Sorry!)

I think primarily it’s because I just want to focus on the main points I’m responding to. There are also instances where I don’t think I can provide a sufficient counter-argument to something someone has written, so I don’t quote that section. Likewise there are instances where I have no interest in responding to a particular section of a post (either because I think someone else in the topic has already provided a better response than I ever could, or because I think the hypothetical idea being presented doesn’t merit my time and effort).

It’s not that I’m trying to present selected quotes in order to take them out of context, I just have no desire to double the length of the post I’m writing by including everything someone else had written. If a user wishes to see all the bits you’d written, then can scroll back up the topic to see your full post.

And I think your post asking me why I write my posts this way proves my point… Before even asking your question, you’d quoted my entire previous post, along with the sections of your previous post I’d embedded, creating a massive body of quoted text that doesn’t even really serve the purpose to your question.

It’s not intentionally malicious, I guess it’s just the habit I’ve fallen into.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]The point I’m making with the writing prompt thing is that this is such a new “thing” we don’t know how it will develop.
[/quote]

It may be relatively new, but we have already seen glimpses of how it’s developing:

•Art websites like DeviantArt (if not being filled) with A.I.-generated art, then certainly being choked with lots of “insta-art”* content, much of which bears the same plasticy feel that a lot of A.I.-generated artwork has. On top of this, submissions of non A.I.-generated art end up getting buried under the deluge of generated work.

And moving away from the writing-prompt side of things:

•A.I. News services (most prominently in this case Apple’s) generating completely false stories.

•A.I. Being used to fake statements and photos of world leaders and politicians in order to stir up local or more widespread hatred. In the case of the Mayor of London I previously mentioned, someone used samples of his voice, fed through an A.I. program to make it sound like he’d disparaged the Armistice Day commemorations that are held in the U.K. in November, and that he’d called for there to be pro-Palestinian marches on the day instead. After the clip went public, it was circulated by far-right groups, which led to a spike in hate speech aimed towards him.

-In Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s case, it was used to map his face onto the movements of an actor’s, in a video which was intended to present the illusion that Zelenskyy was urging the people of Ukraine to surrender.

-And a further example, a high school principal in Baltimore had his life turned upside down and reputation tarnished when an audio clip supposedly of him making racist remarks was posted online. It was later revealed that the audio clip had been made by the school’s athletics director, who had used the school’s computers to create the fake audio clip with A.I. tools. The athletics director’s motive appeared to be to discredit the principal, as the athletics director was being investigated over the theft of $1,916 from the school.

-LINK

I’m not saying A.I. will grow to become something like Skynet in the Terminator films, but I believe it presents a risk of producing art and other creative endeavours in the same vein as fast food: quick, cheap, and cheerful… But ultimately made without heart and, in the long-term, not healthy for us. :whatever:

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]I have seen and posted here, very funny AI created material. Now it’s funny BECAUSE it’s AI.
[/quote]

While these “film ruined by A.I.” videos did produce a bit of a chuckle from me, once that chuckle had subsided, and I reflected on the videos, I was left with my concern over how convincing some bits of them are. While there are sections that are glaringly fake… And I’d hope people of most ages would be able to spot that they are fake, there are bits (like when Kate Winslet brings out and drinks that bottle, or when Billy Zane eats The Heart of the Ocean) that show the line is getting blurred, and that someone with less humoristic intent can use them for nefarious purposes.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]Had I told you 15 years ago NFT’s would be a thing you’d say “that’s reaching” because no one knows how a thing will develop. I don’t know. You don’t know. That’s the point.
[/quote]

I probably would’ve said that, yeah. :slight_smile:

And on the topic of NFTs, it’s my hope that as we hear so little about them these days, it’s a sign that the NFT fad has faded, and that hopefully A.I. art will eventually die the same death.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]In your view is photoshop detrimental? Avid editing? These things have been used to ■■■■ people. To make them think something that isn’t true.
[/quote]

I don’t view Photoshop or Avid editing as intrinsically detrimental (though Photoshop itself is now advertising A.I. features). You’re correct that they have been used for fakery in their own right (and if we go down the years, photographs and celluloid film have been used for all sorts of fakery from the Loch Ness Monster to Georges Méliès).

The difference between those programs and A.I.-generators in being used to create fakery, is that A.I.-programs can generate images, video files and sound clips almost instantly. With Photoshop or Avid it may still take days to get a decent fake ready, with A.I. you might be able to get it ready in time for that day, or the following day’s news cycle.

A brief aside, in relation to creating digital art; Photoshop requires skill and time to create decent, greate, or exceptional works. I wouldn’t trade any of those hours I’ve spent in Photoshop and Illustrator over the years because in the end, I either achieved the piece I was after… Or I assembled something that was very close to what I was after.

An A.I. art generator might be able to give be a loose approximation of the idea I had in my head, but the combination of my pencil, my mouse, Illustrator and Photoshop is what gets me the exact piece of artwork I actually wanted. :slight_smile:

And if I didn’t have the skills to achieve it myself, there would be artists out there who’d be happy to take my commission. :wink:

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]Again we are villainizing a tool instead of those who misuse it.
[/quote]

Some tools earn their negative reputations, and some tools earn their regulation. A.I. may be a slave to the whims of the people who use it, but it still provides an opportunity and a space for people to instantly, or near-instantly, create harmful or misleading content.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]Care to expand on this? It’s become a culture? I find that interesting. What do you mean by this?
[/quote]

A culture of people who are happy to accept the low-effort products of A.I.-generated content because it’s been wrapped up as something that’s cheaper or convenient (see the “fast food insta-art” bit I wrote earlier), a culture where the efforts of actual artists and writers are devalued becuase people with no creative talent can flood creative spaces with their generated content.

It’s a culture that, if suitably ■■■■■■ off and vindictive, can result in spurned employees, lovers or schoolyard bullies creating compromising video and audio files of innocent people… All with the comfort and convenience of their office or school library computers.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]But again. That’s a media literacy problem.
[/quote]

I don’t think it’s just an issue of media literacy. Education definitely plays a part in the problem, but there’s also a person’s intellectual level… Their gullibility level… And some people want to believe the fakes no, matter what evidence is presented to the contrary.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]So while it suck’s a technology will always ultimately get used for nefarious purposes, a daughter hearing her father’s voice? That’s beautiful.
[/quote]

It is beautiful, which is why I advocate that A.I. programs should be subject to regulation.

A.I. voice generators should only be available for purposes like restoring a person’s voice that they’ve lost due to accident or health reasons. It shouldn’t be out there on the internet for any Tom, Dick, or Harry to use for whatever reason they might come up with on a Friday night after a bunch of beers. :whatever:

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]Should people like Dr.D fight like hell to make sure their union contracts include safety precautions so the impacts on jobs will be as minimal as possible? Yes. 100%. But to say there’s no argument? There’s no nuance? Again maybe it’s because my own experience with AI was so positive and emotional but I read things like that and just think “fear. This all based on fear”. And people tend not to make the best choices when fear plays a part in thinking.
[/quote]

That seems a bit of an unfair suggestion to make. They didn’t strike because they’d suddenly given into fear, or a fear-influenced line of reasoning. A lot of their decisions would’ve been based on the track record of every major studio in Hollywood over the decades, and the track record they all have in looking to exploit people.

[quote=GuyX post_id=5002726 time=1736010640 user_id=44443]So far I haven’t seen generative AI create any new problems that didn’t exist beforehand. Fake celebrity endorsements? Not New. Making it seem like someone is saying or doing something they didn’t? Not new.
[/quote]

It hasn’t created anything new yet (which, frankly, is A.I.-generated content largely in a nutshell), but it can make the old problems worse, or easier to achieve.

[/quote]

I wonder if where we come from and our respective cultures might play into how we view AI. You mentioned the word “regulation”. Maybe it’s because I’ve grown up in a society that sees regulation as generally an intrusive thing where the meaning of freedom & how literal one takes that is a regularly debated topic. I come from a place that views guns very differently than others. I respect and understand the arguments made for something like gun control, but I view the 2nd amendment as an essential freedom even though I’m not a gun person.

If I may bring this into a Ghostbusters context for a moment, I imagine if the Ghostbusters were real(and I apologize if this is off topic but I think it’s just an interesting way to look at how we view things) you would be on the EPA/Walter Pecks side of the argument, no? (without condoning the man personally of course just his regulatory zeal & chutzpah)

Oh my no. you’ve got that all wrong. All wrong. I wasn’t saying striking was fear based. Not at all. What im saying IS fear based is the “no argument no nuance” about generative AI. I fully support a workers right to strike. What IS fear based is when we deal in absolutes and say things like “No arguments” when it comes to generative AI having positive attributes. I want to make that very clear. I 10000% supported the WGA/SAG strike and believe that was the right call to make in an industry that all too often ■■■■■ on those who help fuel it.

I don’t think regulating something because people are ignorant is the right way to go. People will believe fake shit all the time. Or not believe real shit. You can’t regulate that. Do you want to regulate supermarket tabloids that have pictures of Jesus marrying an Alien? Because people will believe that. Or other such non sense like Hitler walking around in Argentina. Like we’ve talked about, this isn’t new.

And yes you’ve given many examples of AI being used to drum up a negative response and reaction. All are bad. But AI isn’t any worse than “photoshop” “blender” or “audacity” or “protools”.The only thing that’s new is the access, ease and speed at which these things can be created. But we can’t say the Internet is inherently detrimental because of the speed and ease at which you can gamble away your life savings. That’s a negative aspect of it sure. It sucks. But there’s so much more.

As far as people believing fake shit I actually think the opposite could very well happen just as easily—for the most part. Perhaps AI is going to make more & more people NOT believe. We’ve seen it before AI with the moon landing or flat earthers. And the “fake news” ■■■■ from Trump. AI is another tool in the toolbox of conspiracy nuts. If something major happens, like say we land on mars, “it’s just AI” will be the new “it was faked by Hollywood” or whatever non sense they come up with. Oh sure some will believe fake AI stories but I see people becoming either more vigilant about what they see online and others using its mere existence as a shield against actual photo/video evidence of legit events.

I’m of the opinion that you can’t regulate ignorance. You can only fight it with education and learning.

1 Like

LMAO-- all good, and you’re not wrong. I blazed past “The Real” in his post, I guess because it wasn’t capitalized. Far be it from me to go all grammar teacher on a message board, though. Snark begets snark. :love:

BOSS did have a really talented Japanese lady employed for GB, but she was in the creature shop, not optical.

You also missed the part where I said “80s.” To specify I was remembering an old documentry about how the The real Ghostbusters was made. How they wrote the story and drew the story board then flew it (commerical no less) to Japan. At which point the documentary showed Japanese women linking in the animation cells. A job done in computers now.

That’s correct, both GB and RGB were made in the 80s. Good job! :love:

Oooh, you tricky devil, editing your post after I replied.

Yes, ink and paint animators across the globe transitioned to digital animation. I’m sure some jobs were lost, such as, I don’t know-- paint sales? I’m sure some artists didn’t transition to digital. Tech drives employment like that, although AI will do away with WAY more jobs than the switch to digital in the 90s. Apples and oranges.

The analog/digital switch is heavily covered in Too Hot To Handle: Remembering Ghostbusters II. :love:

It’s not apples to oranges it’s apples to bigger apple. You only feels it’s different because it’s effecting white collar jobs this time.

1 Like

Do you think animators, writers, artists, and the like are white collar jobs? I sure don’t.

****[quote=d_osborn post_id=5002752 time=1736103248 user_id=21]
Do you think animators, writers, artists, and the like are white collar jobs? I sure don’t.

[/quote]

Blue collar means the person does physical labor; factory work, janitorial etc. White collar means the person works in office at a desk. So yes it is white collar work.

Semantics. Compared to janitors and factory workers, sure. In the overall entertainment industry, creatives are absolutely blue collar workers that will be out of work the second studio execs and producers (film biz white collar) think they can get away with it. Storyboard and concept artists— tough rocks. Composers and musicians— hit the bricks, buddy. Background extras— get scanned then get bent. Audio mixers, foley recordists, colorists— good luck in your future endeavors.

Creative work is already hard enough without a nepotism club card. With ai, the regular Joe can forget it.

Yeah it’s rough out there. Now I realize Flim and Tv work is far from stable. But coming from a working class background I’m not going to shed a tear. Because the working class goes through the same thing.

FYI the definition of white collar work is “a salaried professional or an educated worker who performs semi-professional office, administrative, and sales-coordination tasks, as opposed to a blue-collar worker, whose job requires manual labor.” So yeah most of the “creative” jobs like writing and artists are white collar. Flim crew and special effect work are blue collar.

1 Like

“Salaried”, “admin”, and “sales coordination” are not words I would associate with a career in the creative arts. Unless they own the business, most creative professionals I know would run for the hills at a mention of admin or sales. A set salary would be like an unattainable dream.

FYI, here’s where I would copy/paste the definition of semantics.

RE: Regulating the Ghostbusters. It kinda is veering into off-topic, but I’ll bite.

If the Ghostbusters existed in the real world, of course I’d expect them to be regulated… Just like any other company that uses dangerous equipment. I wouldn’t want them to destroy a good chunk of my house whilst trying to bust a ghost. Likewise, if they caused an accident or hurt a pedestrian while racing to a call, I’d expect them to suffer the appropriate repercussions for that.

I’m with Derek, animators, storyboard artists, artworkers and graphic designs feels far more blue collar than white collar. White collar still feels more like admin, legal, HR, Wall Street kinda stuff.

And given how casual workplace attire has got, I’d argue even further that the blue collar/white collar analogy just doesn’t work anymore.

Hey Bison, how long have you worked in film and television? You have a pedantic answer for everything and you keep speaking as if you are part of the industry so I am curious. I’ve worked my way since 2015 up from a production assistant to working in a writer’s room. You wanna love AI and ignore the real world consequences that’s fine, but don’t expect everyone to share your uniformed opinion.

I guessing you’re young, just north of south fourty. So this may not directly apply, since happened in the late 70s and 80s when we were little kids at best. But how did you feel when American factory workers lost their jobs to automation and outsourcing? Let me guess you didn’t even think about them right? So why should I worry about you being effected by new technology?

1 Like

I’m gonna ask Dr.D’s question again, as I think it is pertinent to understanding your point of view. Do you, or have you worked in the film or television industry, Bison? (And to expand on Dr. D’s question:) Or even in a creative industry of some sort?

Kingpin they should just learn to code. Oh wait AI can do that as well. (Note I don’t support fossil fuel industry, but I really you two had any concern for coal miners when they were worried about their jobs.)

1 Like