I’ll take that as a “no”, then… You’ve not worked in film, television, or a creative industry at any point in your life.
If that is the case, then I think that gives a lot of insight into why you seem so blasé about the concerns that have been raised, and the examples that have been cited.
How blasé are you when coal miners or factory workers are worried about lossing their livelihood? You folks think well those people should just adapt and find a new job. Then the moment you see the same thing happing to the Flim and TV industry in the near future, it’s “Oh my god It’s the end of the world!!!” We need UBI, so creative people could make things with out worrying about surviving, but since people rather vote for right wing establishment hacks in both major parties, yes the Democrats are right wing, well tough luck.
Why do you assume those arguing your counter-point only care about film/TV workers? I often work in marketing for manufacturers developing automated equipment for large factory and distribution centers. I’ve seen entire departments laid off from automation, and that was well before AI. It’s not limited to the creative field. John Deere is testing driverless farm equipment down the road from where I live. You want to talk about putting people below the poverty level out of a job, farm hands driving tractors will even be out of a job. The already dying small towns across flyover USA will be caput. If a buck can be saved, it will.
No, the idea of AI-generated fan content doesn’t fill me with excitement. Neither does political talk on a GB forum. Eww.
Do you actually have any proper counter-arguments, or are you just going to keep resorting to straw man "what about"isms? The coal industry in my country was on the decline by the 1970s and then pretty much died in 1984, two years before I was born… So you can imagine I wasn’t exactly in the position to consider what they were going through at the time.
Okay I get it, in your mind “creatives” are more valuable than manual laborour. Technology marches on and people get left behind. There should be a safety net for this situation. But there isn’t. But fundamentally, the loss of coal mining jobs in West Virginia isn’t any more or less tragic than the loss of creative jobs in Los Angeles/New York.
If we were to view the global contributions the creative industry and the coal-mining industry have made to the world, I think the evidence of history would suggest the creative arts did more for humanity in the long run, even if coal helped us get some of the way. Art has certainly done less to poison the environment, not that that’s the fault of the labourers who mined it.
The loss of mining jobs in West Virginia naturally will lead to uncertainty and financial hardship for those people, and nobody’s disputing that. The loss of creative jobs in Los Angeles or New York can lead to us slowly losing what little say and control we have in our culture’s artistic output.
I feel it also worth noting that traditional painting and sculpting would likely qualify as manual labour, given the physical work involved in some of those pieces (especially works like The Night Watch, Guernica, or the roof of the Sistine Chapel.