Bill Murray replaced?

Okay, whats the over/under for how long it takes for the bluff to be called on this one. They say if Murray’s a no show than they’re replacing him with Jack Ryan. Correct me if I’m wrong, but isn’t that the guy who played young Kirk? How would he pull off old Venkman?

I think he was just using him as an example and not in the literal sense…

And being as Murray IS Venkman, I definately see the film tanking if they go this route…“DOA” as they say…

I personally NEVER got used to it when they would change up the actors for any of my favorite characters…Would always take me out of the movie/tv show entirely…‘Dukes Of Hazzard’ anyone?..

While I love Venkman to death, I could deal with his absence if they came up with a good excuse, like he ran off to Vegas with a showgirl or something. With that being said, the fact that they’re thinking of recasting the role if Bill says no is just insulting. Write him out of the script, scrap the movie or convince him to be in it, but do not recast Venkman!

Jack Ryan is a character in the Tom Clancy Novels.

Sum of all Fears played by Ben Affleck

Patriot Games and Clear and Present Danger played by Harison Ford

Hunt for Red October played by Alec Baldwin

But I really don’t think they’re going to replace him. I believe someone at Empire got there wires crossed.

This is just a classic game of telephone gone out of control.

Dan Aykroyd made a comment. Someone took that as Bill Murray being replaced… and as the story skipped across the internet, actors were mentioned. Now those actors are rumored that they are replacing Bill Murray for real. All in the course of 24 hours.

Reminds me of this:

i don’t think that Peter Venkman should be recast, that would be a bad move i think.

a new(simmilar) character to replace Venkman? sure.

i would be sad if Bill Murray decided not to do GB3.

he did the GB video game a few years back and seemed to have a good time doing it.

even if they kill off his character in the first 10 min of the movie i would still be happy that murray was in the movie alive(or as a ghost like Murray asked them to write in the script, and yet still declines).

my only thought on recasting Venkman would have to do with the dimension jumping equipment rumor: Venkman dimension hops, a glitch or short circuit in the machine, and you have a Venkman from a different dimension or even a younger time (younger venkman = younger and new actor).

They should have recast him 28 years ago. Bill Murray sucks.

GASP! :sigh: :angryvigo:

I don’t think Bill Murray sucks at all. But if these rumors are somehow true, I would much rather have a GB3 with either no Venkman, or a different Venkman, than no GB3 at all. Bill Murray is not Peter Venkman in the same way that Robert Englund is Freddy Krueger IMO - nor does a live action Ghostbusters film necessitate Murray in the same way that an Evil Dead film necessitates Bruce Campbell, for example. Ghostbusters doesn’t have a main character, and although I adore the originals, it’s the concept of ghostbusting itself that really attracts people. I’ll take another GB film any way I can get it. It can’t be any worse than XGB.

“Thank you, but I believe my guest MAY disagree with you.”

Just let me disclaim that i’m not trolling.

I really can’t stand some of these people that are OKAY with a remake /reboot and re-casting characters. I’m 24, i’m not some Old head that can’t deal with "change"or what have you. I’m a person that believes if it’s not broken, don’t fix it.

“Ghostbusting” itself was not the attraction. It was the element of humor . “Ghostbusting” could’ve been taken in a more serious route, but with a title like “Ghostbusters” it’s kind of difficult anyway, especially since the concept itself is completely tongue-in-cheek .

Can you honestly picture Ghostbusters being the same movie, without the creative forces of Dan Aykroyd and Harold Ramis?

Sure, RGB was good for what it was, but since it was animated it allowed other actors to fill the shoes, but in our minds we were picturing the actual actors.

I’m sorry but as i said before, I don’t bleieve GB is that translatable a franchise without the originators. It’s not Star Trek, it’s not Star Wars, iit’s a Comedy movie with a witty concept. And with most (good) Comedy films, it is dependent on it’s character quirks, sure we can still have another funny scene with 3 new guys running like hell from a scary library ghost, BUT, it was the attraction to the characters that made us laugh at the situations they were getting in.

I like to think of Ghostbusters as like a modern big-budget “Marx Brothers” film. you can never really replace Groucho, Chico, and Harpo. Just like you can’t replace Murray, Aykroyd and Ramis.

Heh obviously I don’t really think he sucks. His attitude is pretty lame at times though.

Bill Murphy can never be replaced. He will always be Tony Venkman to me.

you can’t replace murray, that’s true but you can leave him behind.

I honestly think he’s behaved like a douche with the production of the film and with his, So they claim to be, Friends. at this point I’d rather see the film take off without him as i just have no more sympathy for the guy.

he want’s to die in the first 10 minutes? so be it! Kill the man! and then make a generated FX ghost of him or something grabbing a pack and busting ghosts with everyone in the nick of time or something. or just claim the asshole retired to malibu and is living his days off between margaritas and big boobed 18 year old chicks.

what pisses me the most is that he alone is holding the production of this movie back and still people keeps kissing his ass. EFF him! Ghostbusters don’t really need him for the film to work for as long as Dan, Harold and Ernie’s passion is holding it together.

Murray was fun a long time ago and he did made the Venkman character fun, douchy and even lovable but that’s IT. Ghostbusters are NOT Venkman, he was a loudmouth and the real brains behind the equipment and stuff where surely Egon and Ray. He jus handled (and fondled) Public Relations and money for the company.

I think there’s a very good reason they don’t want to go on without Murray, aside from the rights issues:

For better or worse, as far as the general ticket buying public goes, he’s the face of the franchise.

Remember when people bitched and complained about Rick Moranis not being in the Video Game? They announced GB3 “But Bill Murray declined to be in it” multiply that by about 100. Moranis played a character that isn’t even important to the franchise (see: RGB, IDW, GBVG, all of which get along fine without Louis); Bill Murray/Peter Venkman, like it or not, is the main star of both movies.

Look, we as ■■■■■■■■ fans know Ghostbusters can be done without Murray or even Venkman. But the movie has to appeal to a wider audience, and he’s the biggest draw of the “old guard”. And no matter how popular any fad actor they cast as Oscar or any sort of “Team Extreme 2.0” , the question of “But why did Bill Murray pass up on this?” will come up, and a lot of the general public may regard it as a sort of canary in the coal mine: “Wow. The script must really suck.” Murray passing on it will sour a lot of people on caring about it before the first frame is even shot.

Again, can it work? Yeah. But it makes a sequel to two movies that are over twenty years old a much harder sell to the public if the biggest star of the originals doesn’t have anything to do with it.

As far as I’m concerned GB was great for 3 reasons:

  1. Great Script

  2. Great dynamic between the characters

  3. It was so original at the time that we were learning about it all right with them.

After the first movie point 3 can never be had again. With someone else as Venkman I doubt we’d have point 2. They might be able to pull it off without Venkman altogether if they have point 1, but that’s a big “IF”

I know that I may be opening a can of worms here, but I loved Tron Legacy. I believe the two actors from the original were well represented. Not to mention Kevin Flynn goes out in a blaze of glory. I know a lot of people run hot and cold on the movie, but you have to admit that’s one hell of a way to pass the torch.

I enjoy Tron Legacy because it showed that a Sequel can work pretty well after 20 years. I have faith that Ghostbusters can pull it off.

@philmorgan81: I would normally agree. You make a VERY good point. The same is true for Star Trek and Superman. My problem would be having only one actor switched out. That’s the kind of thing that is all or nothing for me.

Yeah, I can understand that. :slight_smile:

http://ghostbustersiii.blogspot.com/ here it is…the Recast Murray rumor is not true.

[quote=“rodie”]

I know, I was joking around. You are right though, he can be a jerk. He is still awesome though!

Sent from my SGH-T759 using Ghostbusters Fans on Android