Ernie Hudson's Cameo

That makes no sense though because then why is Bill Murray not Bill Murray and instead some other job. Or Dan being a Taxi driver?

Pretty sure there’s never been a Ghostbuster named Bill Murray.

And it makes sense because actors and characters aren’t the same person. That guy from Groundhog Day wasn’t Peter Venkman, either. Seth Rogan’s dad is not Egon Spengler.

True… but that’s pretty disingenuous. Imagine…

Peter Weller playing a visible character in the Robocop remake and NOT Robocop.

Mark Hamil playing a bar patron in the Force Awakens and NOT Luke Skywalker.

Robert Englund murdered by Freddie Kruger in the Jackie Earle Haley remake.

Christian Bale appearing beside Batman in the new Superman vs Batman film.

Harrison Ford getting into a barfight with a new actor playing Indiana Jones in some future remake.

These characters, in their film context, cannot and will not be associated with any other character. 100% of viewers will see Bill Murray in the reboot and say “Hay, it’s Peter Venkeman”. Bill Murray, in a Ghostbusters film, cannot be associated with anything else. When Ernie Hudson walks on the screen 100% of viewers will say “Why is Winston helping the Ghostbusters?” They are such a part of the cultural identity of Ghostbusters, that they cannot be viewed as anything other than their original characters in such a context.

Quite possibly the best perspective anybody has ever made of this situation…

Those all sound pretty cool, though…

Depends on the person viewing it, though… it may be off-putting to some, if not most, fans…

It’s like John Landis making a Great Dictator remake and Chaplin plays a nazi.

That is 100% incorrect. I will be ‘that guy’ and point out that there will be a significant portion of people watching the movie that have never seen the original or barely remember it at all.

Ghostbusters isn’t government regulated viewing after all.

I speak for the italian moviegoers. Both friends of mine and italians on Facebook whom I asked: “Do you know there is a Ghostbusters reboot coming out directed by Paul Feig starring Melissa McCarthy, Kirsten Wiig, Leslie Jones and Kate McKInnon?”, they all answered:

“Who the hell is Paul Feig?” “Well, the same guy who directed Bridesmaids, THe Heat and Spy” - “ooohhh…■■■■■■ movies”

“Who are Melissa McCarthy and the others??” “Melissa is the girl from Girlmore Girls and the others are SNL alumns” “Oh, the fat girl who cooks…not funny. We don’t know the others”

“Whooaa, a new Ghostbusters movie?? Really?? is the old gang in it???” “No, it’s a complete reboot with no ties to the original movies” “Aww, not interested”

Good luck, Paul Feig.

Unless Bill Murray IS Peter Venkman in Feigbusters, then millions of registered voters that see this movie will be very, very disappointed.

I will post the Italian opening weekend numbers here. We shall see how it does.

ok, i’m curious too. Maybe a good trailer be enough to gain interest :slight_smile:

A good trailer is always needed to gain interest, especially with a movie like this where we’ve seen nothing but still photos and experience of Feig’s style in older movies… Let’s face it, biggest problem this movie has right now (other than it being a reboot) is the fact that a lot of people aren’t fond of Feig and McCarthy…

There really is no gray area with either of them. You either like them or hate them and if she’s the “star” and not part of the ensemble, then Feig essentially made a sci/fantasy vehicle for McCarthy and used Ghostbusters as his platform. I’m sure the Mccarthy faithful will see it, but I have this suspicion that the trailer will be McCarthy laden and less about the “Ghostbusters”

Really? Where did you get that idea?

Was the original Ghostbusters “all about” Bill Murray, at the expense of the other Ghostbusters?

Was Bridesmaids “all about” McCarthy, at the expense of the other cast members? That was directed by Feig.

I don’t know why you would have the worry that the new movie will be a McCarthy vehicle. Feig has directed ensembles before, they didn’t turn into the Melissa McCarthy show.

I have a lot of worries about the new movie, but that isn’t one of them.

Yes, but Ivo,

McCarthy is a bigger star now than she was in Bridesmaids. And she’s his go-to-girl ala Johnny Depp to Tim Burton, so yeah I’d have a feeling she’ll be much more prominent than the others

True. McCarthy was more of just a side character in Bridesmaids.

Obviously, I can’t stop people from coming up with whatever they want to, but the idea that these guys are living under new identities just seems like the most desperate bit of mental gymnastics I can imagine. Is it really that vital to you guys? It makes no sense – how many people saw the Stay-Puft Marshmallow Man, or walking Lady Liberty, or the museum covered in slime? The game is set in 1991, bringing the public’s awareness of the Ghostbusters even further forward. McCarthy’s character is supposedly invested in proving that ghosts exist, yet she would somehow have to have done this research after the Men in Black apparently showed up to brain-wipe the entire city of New York, and presumably all of the world, since they had a ceremony on Liberty Island once the statue was back. She’d have already been 21 years old in 1991 (if we assume she’s the same age as McCarthy).

My understanding is that the deal for Ghostbusters II may also have made it legally necessary for Sony to specify that these guys are playing other characters.

The cameo thing is a no-win. If none of them were in it I bet you guys would think it was disrespectful, more of Feig throwing out the baby with the bathwater. Now that they’re in it, it’s a shameless ploy by Sony to help sell the movie.

McCarthy was more of a side character in Bridesmaids but that film was also pitched as an ensemble. She’s a co-star in The Heat which is pitched as a buddy comedy, and a star in Spy which is centered around her character. Her prominence shifts with the movie, so I have no reason to believe Ghostbusters won’t go right back to being an ensemble.

I agree with everything you said. The cameos are cameos. They’re not Venkman, Stantz, and Zeddemore. They are different people.

I hope not. That would be a big mistake, I think.