I can’t speak for anyone else, but the reason I’m against a reboot is that it seems to miss the point of what gives Ghostbusters it’s magic in the first place…or at the very least where that magic came from. According to Ramis, in Dan’s original script, the three Busters were almost completely interchangable. They had no personalities at all. This was because Dan knew the personality would rely on the person cast in the role. The script was just the bones. Ramis, Akyroyd and Murray all have backgrounds in improv, and it was by playing off of each-other that they constructed the characters we know. Egon, Ray, and Peter exist because of those three actors, with their three abilities, all in the right place at the right time. They CREATED these guys, they weren’t cast as them.
…It’s fully possible for a talented young actor…like, say, Chris Pratt… to be cast as Dr. Peter Venkman, given a clever script, get some laughs and go home without embarrassing himself or his character. But he’s PLAYING Peter. He’s not really Peter.
That’s the difference.
I don’t think you should NEED to reboot anyway. The premise is flexible enough to move in a new cast and make them compelling without having to chuck out all the continuity. It’s been 30 years. There should be other franchises open now, technology has advanced and gone wireless (ghost-traps are probably automatic now, like they were in the video game), it’s a post 9-11 world, the New York franchise is under new management, there’s a corporate headquarters, all that good stuff… -start from there.- You can tell almost any story in this setting. You shouldn’t start all over. It’d be such a waste.
He was part of the hypothetical early-90s Ghostbuster cast. Chris Rock was another member of that hypothetical cast. There was someone else I’m forgetting.
Sad thing is, the original guys would have probably still been up for it in the 90s. (Yeah, Bill Murray would have been evasive and made a fuss, but if it was happening with or without him and came down to the wire at the 11th hour he would have SHOWN UP, like he did for the video game)
We didn’t need a New Generation in the 90s. What I think we need is more people willing to call Bill Murray’s bluff. He won’t ever admit it, but he couldn’t STAND to let GBIII happen without him. I am almost sure of it.
“What’s it got to do with EA?” I hear you say. Well, nothing, but if you swap “EA” for “Sony” then you get the idea. [EA has taken some great games (like Need For Speed) and turned them into ■■■■. The same has happened with Activision and the Call of Duty franchise].
If Sony couldn’t be bothered to restore Ecto-1a for the fans (or even let us buy it and do it ourselves) what makes you think they’ll give a ■■■■ about how good the new film is? The ONLY reason Sony would let this happen, is because it will make them a load of cash with little or no effort.
In this day and age, companies find something good and flog it until they’ve squeezed every last penny out of the idiot consumer base (again, refer to the video I’ve posted).
If GB3 happens, so will GB4, GB5 and GB6… and they’ll turn out just like Die Hard: a load of CGI drivel.
as in a LEGO Ghostbusters movie? huh. there would have to be a lot of merch (actual LEGO sets, not just the upcoming cuusoo set, a LEGO GB game, etc) for me to get interested. maybe get the RGB license too and release RGB LEGOs as well…
And that might actually be the best news the GB movie world has had in a long time. These guys are currently the kind of undiscovered gems of comedy filmmaking, though their profile has been getting marginally higher with each project. And they haven’t made a bad film yet.
I am, and will probably forever be fearful of a new movie. Let sleeping dogs lie, is my take on a new film. My first and major concern is the Vehicle, because I seriously doubt a “new crop” of ghostbusters, will be interested in having a nearly 60 year old car, as their work vehicle. Closely following my concern about the Caddy being put out of commision, is the writing, storyline, and most of all who would, fill the shoes, of Aykroyd, Ramis, Murray, and Hudson. It would be very hard to capture the essence of what Ghostbusters, really was. I just can’t see actors of today,(although many are funny, they aren’t that kind of funny) standing up to the talent, that, that movie delivered originally. I guess because Ive loved GB since I was 5 years old (I am 30 now) every time I watch the movie, which is quite often, it still makes me feel like a lil kid, and I seriously doubt anything new could ever give me that same feeling again. I think some things are better left alone. Harold and Dan, did a great job on the game, maybe that should have been the last chapter of the GB, because honestly IMO, I am not interested in seeing anyone else be a GB. Those 4 dudes, were the ghostbusters, and anything new would just take away the luster of what it was all about. I know we are all hungry for anything GB, but maybe just keeping, things the way they are, will preserve its legacy. I will say however, Emma Stone coming in as I don’t know, lets say Janine’s daughter, might entice me to go see a new GB. This is just my opinion, not trying to ruffle anyones feathers. Just thought I’d offer my take on things, although I am sure I am pissing someone off. Cheers
Emma Stone? Why? She’s perfectly charming and conventionally beautiful and she’s already been in Zombieland with Bill Murray, but I don’t get the impression that she’s a comedic genius of our time.
Then again, I don’t think anyone really expects The Girl to be funny. She will ground the team and give the underdog hero something to strive for, but she’ll be setting up everyone else’s jokes, not getting the laughs herself.
It’s sad because it makes people think genuine female comedians don’t exist. They do. They just don’t get hired.
With Ramis dead and Murray likely a no-show, maybe they should reconsider this movie being a pass-the-torch sequel. Maybe they should be thinking about a reboot.
That is not what I mean at all. She is severely talented, and I made the initial comment as a joke, because I find her to be very attractive, as well as very talented. My point was I don’t want a new GB movie, and Emma Stone as any character could be a persuading character to get me to see it. I am not saying in anyway shape or form, that she couldn’t be important or good enough to be a dynamic character. She seems to be doing pretty well in her, comedic, as well as dramatic career, and being a feisty redhead, playing a character like Janines’ daughter that now works at GB headquarters would be a cool thing, that doesn’t mean that she or any other woman, couldn’t be a funny, key, or other important/intelligent character.
I just don’t see any way for this to be good. Like a previous poster mentioned, Ghostbusters was good because of THOSE ACTORS playing THOSE CHARACTERS. Not just the concept. Everything came together just right.
The humor in Ghostbusters was more subtle, character-based humor… stuff that nobody seems to be doing anymore. Everything is over the top.
I mean, I’m a hardcore TMNT fan, and some of you have probably seen the trailer… I’m afraid of something like that.
Murray will show. He’ll moan and complain and be evasive, but at the end of the day, his pride won’t let them make it without him. As hard as being in it would be, NOT being in it would probably be harder. Someone will call his bluff eventually.
…if it turns out he’s NOT bluffing, well, uh… :walterpeck: whoops.
Is a “feisty redhead” the deciding factor in all of your movie-going decisions? Because as far as character descriptions go…that’s not a lot to go on. I, for one, am tired of “Fiesty” and “strong female character” labels. They’re often used as stand-ins for personality and I think we should demand better.
Besides, there’s all the difference in the world between “an actress who can be funny,” and a real comedian. I, for one, hope they cast the latter. Living up to the bar set by the original cast is going to be almost impossible, and if this girl can do it, then I don’t care if she looks like a fish, a walrus, or voodoo doll constructed from beef jurkey. Can she make me laugh? Can she engage me on a level where I’m not sure where she ends and her character begins? That’s all that matters.
Also, making the Next Generation of Ghostbusters the LITERAL Next Generation is lame. I don’t want to see everyone’s sons and daughters working together. Even Star Trek didn’t do that.
Jesus, I am becoming sorry that I posted on this at all. The main point of my post was that I am against any new GB film. The Stone thing was said in jest!
I actually find this fairly likely. In any interview where he’s actually asked about it, it doesn’t flat say ‘no.’ He just says the script has to be good. Could he just be covering his ass? Possibly. He could very easily want not to be involved at all, but it does speak to his ego, given that it could be one last hurrah for him as a pop culture icon. The last time a GB movie came out, he was still stuck in comedyland, but now that he’s successfully broken away, the idea of getting back into it with Dan and Ernie might make him give on it.
I even remember one interview where he says that young people he partied with would all gang up on him and talk about how great it’d be if he came back, which leads him to ponder if he should just go ahead and do it. Bill has a love/frustration relationship with the franchise, but not hate. If there was, he wouldn’t have signed his likeness away for the recent toys and he sure as Hell wouldn’t have been in the game.
He’s always evasive. Yeah, he gave Terminal Reality a hard time about doing the game, but he did it. And didn’t Aykroyd once say that they didn’t know for sure he’d do GB2 until he showed up on the set the first day of shooting?
It’s just as likely Murray will sit it out. But if not, if he likes the script and is excited by the directors, and digs the idea of one last big movie hurrah with Dan, out of respect for Harold… he may just show up on the first day of shooting.
(And, I’d be willing to bet, if he agrees, they’ll use a script that includes the originals more prominantly)