

http://ghostbustersnews.com/2017/07/16/female-dr-news-give-us-insight-ghostbusters-backlash/
Thatâs really too bad about the differences in reactions there, although hopefully it wonât drop below 65% likes. Hopefully the reaction will be milder. Unfortunately I remember some of the promos for Ghostbusters looked like they may get a positive reaction at first, but then the wave of negativity would come. ![]()
This doc Who season will be in continuity and not a full reboot, so I think it will be ok.
With ghostbusters we could have had the same female cast but the movie wrote as a sequel and we wouldnât have faced all that backlash.
While GB:ATC has enough legitimate reasons to dislike itâs premise, especially after seeing it, I think the main takeaway from the article is how people underestimated/downplayed the shear initial amount of mysoginist backlash.
Weâre already seeing the usual âfeminism is ruining Dr Who!â nonesense. Fandoms will never be OK. They are ill. I donât watch Dr. Who but even if I did, I canât go down this road with a fandom again. Iâm tired of it.
I do see some GB fans support the female DoctorâŚjust so they can stick it to ATC one more time. Same with Wonder Woman.
Iâm tired of it.
Next to Ghostbusters, Doctor Who is one of my top fandoms, and I am very excited about what this new Doctor will bring to the show. It will be very similar to the Ghostbusters experience, for whenever Iâm out in my Doctor costumes (2, 4, 5, or 12), people are going to come up to me and expect that Iâll complain with them about the character being a woman.
I donât think this gives any insight. When photos came out for Ecclestonâs Doctor people complain that the new show was going to be too dark and intense. By the time Matt Smith was picked people were complaining that they were going to make the Doctor younger and younger to attract young fans. Then Capaldi was announced and people were outraged that he was too old. There is always outrage about the Doctor. There was anger towards Torchwood featuring a gay lead. So at this point the fandom has had fights over show intensity, the looks of the actors, the age of the main character (both for being too young and too old) and the sexuality of characters. Gender is far from the first âWhy is any one fighting about this?â argument held among Who fans.
As a long time fan I donât care what they do with the Doctor. Iâve found 2005 onward to be garbage and so far from what the intention of the Franchise was that itâs only Doctor Who in name only.
Iâve simply walked away from Doctor Who because it only took 6 hours to get to the reboot levels of infighting our fandom took 6 months to accomplish. Iâm not going through that again. Sadly the ratings have been falling steadily since Matt Smith left which is bad news for starters and shaking 54 years of established lore is going to make it an extremely up hill battle for Chris Chibnall and Jodie Whittaker. If it doesnât work (which could very well be given the already present backlash) then the show gets cancelled (which I donât want) or she only lasts a season, the show reverts back to its previous form with a man in the lead role and the 13th female regeneration becomes a joke moving forward. So thereâs not really a lot of positive going forward.
I wonder if the death threats have started⌠Anyone seen Cassidy?
Can Chris Chinball produce decent, new science fiction stories to keep Doctor Who fresh?
VS
Can Paul Feig produce a funnier, scarier Ghostbusters?
If not, you could still dismiss the âwomanâ thing on a flaw with being granted a second regeneration cycle. ![]()
I mean, â â â â âŚthey can re-write just about any ârulesâ to justify keeping the show going.
âWho knows what adventures theyâll have between now and the time the show becomes unprofitable?â
Doctor Who really stopped for me when they introduced Romana II, so they can do as they please as far as I am concerned.
Depends on which audience you talk to, FOS. There are alot of new GB fans that exclusively like the reboot and had no interest in the franchise before that who feel like the reboot is better. Same thing is happening in Doctor Who. You have either strictly Nu-Who fans or casual more feminist leaning fans who herald this as the greatest thing ever who may or may not even stick around for the long haul vs long time fans who just want a quality show, understand the 54 year old lore and are worried that the casting will derail the show further. I personally am walking after the Christmas episode. It will end 10 years of the revival series and the 12th Doctorâs arc for me. And I donât want to watch the show die a slow death if things go south this season.
I donât know much about the show, but from what everyone tells me, Doctor Who is about being open minded, about variability. Itâs interesting that so many of its fans arenât taking those lessons to heart. But really, thatâs true of all fandoms. Rocky Horror for instance, was about shattering social norms, being different. Yet the minute the show broke from tradition with that TV movie, the fans revolted. Fans fear change, even if the story they love celebrates it.
People make fun of âcasuals,â but frankly, they often have a better grip on what a storyâs about than the hard cores, who lose all perspective.
Well Iâm glad that all of us (and I mean every single Ghostbusters fan) took Ghostbusters IIâs positivity message to heartâŚ
Sometimes..sometimes itâs also about karate-chopping monsters and driving hovercrafts.
The Pertwee series got as far as the show needed to go with companions and romantic relationships:
Simple, beautiful, and unmatchedâŚespecially compared to that blubbery Rose nonsense.
I wonder if they are going to make the 1st Doctor âokayâ with all this âwoman businessâ or will he be whisked away before the transformation?
Yâknow, like when Grandpa has to pass away before your cousin can come out to the family?
Thatâs how I feel. What happened to Doctor Who is now happening to DC shows on CW and Fox. They are being turned into teen dramas with unnecessary romance stories. It all started after Harry Potter got so big. They all want to fight for that tween audience.
For me what killed the show was recasting the first Doctor. They changed so much about the show and I thought it should have ended long ago. Iâve argued 2005 on focused too much on romance but I accepted that perhaps regenerations from 2005 on were just extra â â â â â . But they began to change to much history. They donât even do it well. It sounds like terrible fan fiction. But now to bring the first Doctor back to use him as they please is terrible.
It reminds me of what Disney did in destroying the Star Wars history. There isnât any respect for the work done before hand. The revival of Doctor Who started with at least a little bit of respect for the franchise now they are telling us, the fans, we are wrong and they are right. That is fine for new stuff but they are changing things that have been held true for decades and simply cover it up by saying many times âThe Doctor was just lying when he said âXXXXXXXâ years agoâ
My first introduction to Doctor Who was through my brothers showing me episodes from the 1980s when I was really young, and been a strong fan ever since (I even have a replica of Sylvester McCoy, the 7th Doctorâs costume), and have more TARDIS toys than I may be willing to admit to (a compensating response to not having any non-DIY TARDIS toys when I was younger). I was initially a bit conflicted on learning that Jodie Whittaker had been chosen to play the 13th Doctor, but after having a night to sleep on it, Iâm happy to accept her as the new owner of the TARDIS. That isnât me wanting to stick it to the fans whoâve responded with bile and anger (either for the casting decision or Answer The Call), thatâs me trying to live by the showâs idea: times change, as does the Doctor, and that weâre better for being open-minded than for being closed-minded and angry.
The show has lasted 54 years on the premise that the titular character changes, sometimes in quite drastic ways⌠and as changing genders is now part of the established canon, this was an inevitable development (on a note, I donât necessarily see the 14th Doctor being female, but itâs quite possible the 15th might be, it probably wonât fall into a male-female-male-female pattern, but a random one dictated by whoever happens to be the best contender, regardless of their gender). Iâm heartbroken by the response from some of my fellow Whovians⌠especially after having seen the Ghosthead community split so badly, and Iâm concerned about Jodie and Chris getting the blame for the show underperforming when the fault lay more with the outgoing showrunner.
Not that I try to spend much time thinking about him, but maybe this news will be the final blow to make him burst a nerve and have an aneurism.
Iâm trying to wrap my head around this comment⌠why are you unhappy with Bradley portraying the first Doctor? He was brilliant in An Adventure in Space and Time, and heâs not the first actor to take over the role of the first Doctor after William Hartnell passed away, there was Richard Hurndall in 1983âs The Five Doctors, who gave a commendable performance⌠it wasnât absolutely perfect, but it feel within acceptable tolerances.
For all we know he might have been brought back to fill a pivotal role, maybe even help user in a new nu-who era that falls more in keeping with classic Who? Doctor Who does have the rare privilege of actually being able to travel back to the beginning in a way if it so wished.
Moffat did a lot of bad for the show, but heâs gone now. Chris Chibnall may well be a breath of fresh air that the show has been needing, someone who helps ground it better, presents better stories and treats the old stories with greater reverence and less convenience than recent showrunners.
If it helps at all, guys, if you think Ghostbusters and Dr Who have problems, they are minor compared to what the Muppets are going through right now; they are literally falling apart. Last few projects bombed embarrassingly. Disney firing Kermitâs performer. He claims heâs been trying to protect the integrity of the character. Then out of nowhere one of Jim Hensonâs kids apparently said, eh, I never liked your Kermit anyway and youâre lying when you say my father left him to you! YiiikesâŚTalk about your throw downsâŚ
We are starting to arrive to a point where the drama surrounding your shows decides if people will like it.
Youâre right, and it is ridiculous. Fans have to get a grip and understand drama behind the scenes isnât anything new, even with movies and TV shows they love. It doesnât take away from the quality of the product. It just means the product was created by imperfect human beings who are all just trying to get by in life.
One time on new Doctor Who, they featured a â â â â â â â reference with a character that had been transformed into a tile with just a face. This episodeâs monster was designed by a child in a contest on another long-running childrenâs show.
And weâve been over here arguing about ghost bjs and queefs!