Let's Compare..

I know we keep saying that humor is subjective and all, but try as I might I can’t find anything or remember anything that was, in my mind, LOL worthy. I don’t even remember anyone else in my theater having a good laugh - it was actually pretty somber.

Exactly! Sometimes I’m not so good at expressing myself.

Oh I’m the same way, I still don’t think “grin” is exactly the right word. Hmm…

This is like saying the Halloween remake was more scarier because there were more jump scares than the original. Does it make it a better film? No. But hey, at least it made you jump.

None of us said funnier. We said they provoke different reactions.

They’re both funny in different ways.

Makes perfect sense to me.

You could probably hear a pin drop.

What I loved about the scene in the 84 film is Ray coming in the car and Bill Murray almost getting himself run over trying to stop the car from parking. Oh and the line about the price was great, something “only 48 hundred”. :lol:

I think I like the Cadillac ambulances more than the GMC ones, they seem to look more like the Ecto-1 (possibly more so than the 80s Cadillac hearses.)

Actually, nothing would have stirred shit other than you beating the dead horse of your contempt for a harmless movie.

The only reason it failed was bitter fans and a lack of taste. It was fun, but everyone got hung up on their little baby fanboy problems.

3 Likes

Just because you type them online doesn’t turn your opinions into facts.

We all know they’re opinions. :wink:

A thing both sides can learn from. Let’s all show we can be adults about this and keep the mudslinging out of this thread.

image

Well I can understand the initial discussion has run its course. I’ll have to come up with a new comparison. :wink:

Looks like I’ll have to repeat what I said earlier: I do wonder why we praise the subtlety and class of GB84, but then go so, I don’t know, 5th grade with criticism of the reboot. You’d think GB fans would draw more on the biting wit of GB84 (and I’ll include GB89 as well), but no, it’s typical fanboy stuff. Interesting.

Let’s keep the bar high, and avoid the temptation to post meme videos from Youtube, folks. :slight_smile: There’s potential for more worthwhile discussion here.

Next round of discussion. What are the major differences between proton pack technology from both films?

The biggest difference between the packs is of course that they use a syncrotron instead of a cyclotron to accellerate the particles, like it was pointed out in the tech video!

But I have to point out that the development of the new packs feels a bit forced to me. Like it happens way too fast.

The original movie seemed like it was covering a long span of time while the new one looks like it’s all happening within a week.

In the '84 movie it took them some time before they could open business. After they were removed from the college, they had to get a mortgage from the bank to buy the firehouse which usually takes some weeks to go through. Then they had to do major repairs to the building, which also would’ve taken some time. They had seen the ghost of the librarian and have taken measures from her, before they were evicted from college. So Egon had quite some time to come up with theoretics for the pack and build it, before they opened business.

Now, if we look at the new movie, they see the ghost in the Eldridge Mansion and find one of Rowan’s devices, meaning that his plan is already in full swing. Then they’re forced out of college and don’t have the money to rent the firehouse much less the safeties to get a loan to buy some property and go to the chinese place immediately. They haven’t even moved in completely before Patty appears and takes them to the subway station, but magically Holtzmann already has a pack prototype ready by the time they get there. When the hell did she build that thing?

And also she comes up with a new part or improvement after every job they take. Seems like she had already build the parts before the movie even starts and now just slaps them together to test which combination of parts works the best. But that makes no sense, because they had not seen a ghost before they got to the mansion and had no measurements to base the tech on before.

I really like the new packs but to me it felt like they’re developing too fast in a too short period of time.

1 Like

Yeah I feel like they set up Holtzmann to be the Donatello of the group, where he would have a new machine built every episode because he’s just that brilliant, lol. Holtzmann is that same kind of inexplicable child prodigy. Egon and Ray are more down to earth (not by much though, hehe).

Also, I get the impression they rushed through some beats in GB16 to avoid being redundant with GB84. They spent more time on scenes that were different (Erin worrying about ridicule, she and Abby fighting, etc).

Maybe it’s the beer she’s missing with her Pringles?

image