I had a question, probably more of an opinion kind of thing. I have every Kenner MIB (the entire collection isn’t all originally sealed mint in box) role playing toys, vehicles, and weapons. If I decided to break the seals on the boxes would it hurt the value of the toys?
Beyond being a fan I’ve spent a lot (probably like other fans) collecting these toys as an investment as well. I know one of the factors would be the current market at the time.
Seriously, they will lose nearly all of their value. Sealed toys (especially when the boxes are also “mint”) are always prized by collectors in the secondary market. If you open 'em, then you lose a lot of your potential buyers; among them those buyers that will often pay through the nose to get a figure/toy that they want.
On the other hand, if you want to enjoy your toys by opening them… go for it. That’s what they’re for. But, I wouldnt count on making a buck off them in the future if you do
You bought them to enjoy them right? Are you enjoying them in their boxes?
Anything you try to sell is only worth what someone is willing to pay for it. When I am shopping on E-bay I personally could care less about the box. So for someone to charge $500 for a KennerProton pack in a box that’s never been open, makes me look right past them and on to the person asking $30 for the same thing in a slightly damaged box.
IMO these people that are selling JUST the boxes for things need to be shot, but then I guess if there are people dumb enough to buy JUST a box for hundreds of dollars. I saw an Xbox box, just the cardboard box it came it. not even the packing material inside, sell for $300. :shock: I don’t know how much Xboxes sold for back then but I think the $300 could have gone toward buying a whole system, with a box.
I’m with you on the toys for the enjoyment part, but as a collector’s point of view, there are differences. I found a Tyridium shuttle on a flea market fifteen years ago, for 60 marks (our local currency at the time, equals to 65-70 USD now). At the time, 60 marks was a big sum of money, but now that equals to 10 Euro’s. Still, for the price, it was a steal.
Now, a collector shop had the very same toy, in a box that was battered, but still intact, for over 300 Euro’s. It was sold very fast. I would not have bought it, for that price, even with the box on it. I am VERY happy with the cheap one I got.
But, I can understand the collector’s point on the boxed one. The boxes are VERY old, and depending on condition, hard to come by. The first Star Wars toys did not even get to the Christmas market way back, and the genious decission was to make preorder boxes, that you could buy, and then get the toy shipped to you when it was made. Those sold out, and everyone was happy. Now, a vintage toy collector that wants a complete collection needs those preorder boxes, that are not used (I mean they are bought, but not redeemed for the figures). In reality, the very box HAS become a collector’s item, however absurd that would be.
As the GB toys were marketed for kids, they were in almost every instance ripped open, and played with. If, there are some mint boxed sets around, they are valuable, until opened. This is a decission point to the owner. The COLLECTOR value on the mint toys from years back, drops to zero if the seals are opened. Then, it is just a toy among others.
As for the Matty line of GB figures, I’ve opened every pack that I have. I did not buy them for collector’s reasons, and I do not see them as an investment. There was way too many of them made, to become valuable in the near future.
Still, if someone buys them, keeps them safe for decade or two, the new Matty line WILL be valuable, to a collector, if it is mint. As for the old Kenner boxed sets, they ARE decades old, and from a time when there was no toy collectors at large.
Selling just the boxes is a two fold thing. Collectors who have the toy, but not the box, may want the box to complete their box. Sellers might want to buy them so their item is more valuable to a collector. Some sellers, particulary on the new LEGO items, are parting the figures, and other bits and sell them separately. Some keep the packs sealed and sell them for more money. I would not buy a box for an XBOX, but some collector might want that.
It really is a thing for the owner of the toy, if he wants to open the toy or not. On vintage collector’s items, it is not wise to do so, as the value drops immediately. But, if you buy an item to play with, you have to open it..
Oh no doubt. I understand the collectors point of view 100%. I have a few toys still in their unopened packages. Like my Dick Tracy action figure I got back when the movie came out, I also got one to open and play with
Sadly the Dick Tracy figure is not worth much today, the rare to find “The Blank” figure is worth from $500 - $1900.00 on Ebay. Wish I had found one of these back when I was a kid.
As a collector my two cents is to leave your items sealed. Mint in box keener ghostbusters toys are hard to come by. There is some thing special as a collector to have a mint sealed item that has never been open. If you want one open to enjoy, I recommend buying a lose item to enjoy.
Sent from my ADR6400L using Ghostbusters Fans on Android
If I did break the seals on the Kenner boxes, in part I’d want to get enjoyment from them. It’s not about applying sticker decals and displaying them.
:lol: I’m really not much of a football fan. Although seeing as how most of my family are ■■■■■■■■ Giants fans they could be my team too. It’s possible the game wasn’t over yet when I posted, it should have been by the time you did.
Was that a joke about yours being worth more if i did open mine? I’m not trying to start an argument nor do I want to argue. I couldn’t tell from your post.
Something to consider 25 years from now.
I bought them to enjoy (and display when I can make that happen) and for a possible long term investment. I’m not really enjoying them in their boxes as they’re in storage in my house. I agree about the actual value being what someone, like on eBay is willing to pay foe them. It’s probably why i overspent on some of the toys. I know condition can affect the value of a MISB or MIB item too.
Unless an item has been graded (another conversation) some of these eBay sellers way overestimate what an item is worth. To use your example of the pack, I saw last year on eBay a seller was asking a $1,000 on a Kenner MISB proton pack. The seller claimed it was “case fresh.” Maybe it was, I would never pay that much. I’m pretty sure it didn’t sell and I saw re-listed at half the original asking price.
For the most part (unless maybe a box I was damaged, thankfully hasn’t happened) I would never just buy a toy box from someone, especially if it was being sold on eBay.
With Matty’s GB figures, I do keep them in their original unopened cards. I didn’t buy them for an investment first. I wanted them for the reasons most of here would want them. Even if it was costly (again, what one is willing to pay) the line is available.
you could always take photos of your packages, print them out and assemble them into a “box”, or some kind of display piece, buy a loose version of that toy on ebay, and display the loose toy in front of the fake box, then you’d still have your unopened originals, which will likely be used as currency after the 12/21/12 apocalypse.
This topic reminds me of the episode of Home Improvement when the boys got some money from their dead aunt or whatever. Tim took them to a trading card store. They ended up buying an autographed R/C race car for a semi-large amount of money. They brought it home and Tim put it right on the shelf to collect dust.. I mean look at. Later the kids took it out to play with it, wrecked it and.. well, you know the rest.
Point is. When it comes to collectable toys, it’s a hard line to walk. Open them, play with them and enjoy them? Or pack them, display them, dust them and hope to sell them later to someone that will most likely open them, play with them and enjoy them.
The Disk Tracy 'The Blank" figure I mentioned above. I would never pay $500 for it. I might pay $20 for one. If it was MISB, I would open it, break out my figures and play with them. I am looking for one already opened.
Anyway… Whatever you decide, just enjoy them. Whether it be displaying them, or playing with them. Remember that in the end, You can’t take them with you.
You would… play with them? I hope in this hypothetical scenario, you’re also seven years old.
OP: I would keep what you have in the boxes. If you really want access to what’s inside, you can easily buy already opened versions of the same toys in good condition, and save yourself a bunch of scratch. Look at your MIB stuff as an investment, because if it really does exemplify the “M” in MIB, you can definitely make some money off of them down the line, should you choose to sell.
I am 33 years old. and yes I still play with my action figures. Me and my 4 year old son get them out and play with them. or heck I will just be sitting at the computer and take some down off the shelf and play while I wait for a movie to load or something.
Just because I am an adult does not mean I can’t be a kid at heart some times.