The Great GB1 Belt Debate

Ok so there have been a lot of discussions about the color of the first movie’s pistol belts. Some say white, most say gray and a few say khaki.

I think it is fairly obvious these belts were NOT white. I mean if they were white they were dragged in some gravel and dirt for about 3 hours and never washed. It just doesn’t fit…

Gray! It definitely seems like the obvious answer, for years I thought so. They could of easily bought a white belt and dyed it like the pads (if they managed to get cotton belts at the time nylon does not dye). But I firmly believe they only could have been dyed to this gray if this is the case. I have never seen ANY belt reproduction or original labeled as Gray to have that color. Anything labeled as gray usually has a weird Olive Drab color. The closest I have found will be below…

Khaki! For a while I scoffed at this but the more and more I look around the more I buy it. They would not be a true Khaki though and especially not a clean WWII belt those things were deep colored. But as I have looked around I have seen some that look very close to the screen color labeled as Khaki especially M36 reproductions (which has a great beige color) and a number of used ones claiming to be originals. It would seem very possible to be (more then finding a gray belt that seems not to exist or dyeing a white cotton belt) that these could of been what was found for the movie.

Or secret option number 4! M36 WWII Pistol Belt OD#3

That is right. These belts have a weird gray tint to them while almost looking beige or khaki in certain lights. Finding 4 of these belts reproduced or originals may have been difficult or really easy I am not sure. But these could certainly fit the part. But there is a lot of argument on what is truly OD#3 and what is just now called a Khaki or Beige.

Here are the comparison pictures:

Original M36 Khaki

But even that page reads:

“Yes, they are od3 in color, but there are about 20 different shades amongst them so they may or may not be your shade. None of them are the later OD #7 color. Being that these are absolutely, 110% original WWII, the authenticity of their color is beyond question.”

Color comparison on WWII Web gear (not a great representative because the material is aged and very different then the pistol belts but you get the idea) Really shows the gray in the OD#3

Left to right: Khaki, OD #3, OD#7

What says is an OD#3 Pistol Belt (very beige)

A eBay auction claiming it is an originla Khaki M36 belt

http://cgi.ebay.com/M1936-Khaki-Pistol-belt_W0QQitemZ140338965847QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item20acdaad57&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14

Two Reproduction Khaki

My conclusion? Grey is out of the equation to me now. They just aren’t out there and the on screen belts take on too much of a beige look sometimes and certainly while not having the desert tan/deep khaki or the uniforms they aren’t the deep pearl gray of the pads either. If you are going the gray route its simple, they were custom.

Looking at OD#3 clothes would also throw that out the window they get too dark and green tinted but belts, web material, and even a few shirts have a cool gray or beige tint. I’m also feeling that original’s throw a big wrench in the machine for the most part because so much has changed (you can read up on this if you want it gave me a headache so I’ll save you from quoting it here or talking about it). Khaki reproduction’s seem real real close to me and even a few originals (but could those really be an OD#3?). I lean more towards the khaki belts, they seem to fit on the largest scale. But be aware the the GB2 khaki belts are much different and probably a desert tan nylon belt not a cotton M36 reproduction.

So who is confused?

That’s some pretty significant evidence that hints at the possibilty that what was originally presumed may, in fact, not be the unequivocal truth(!)

Seriously, though, that brings up good points, and I’ve always wondered if any of the long time ghostheads had ever talked to a member of the costuming dept of the first movie. And, if they would be willing to share some information if they did.

I have no doubt they used cotton reproduction belts. And as you said, I’ve never found a gray one that color. In fact, I’ve only ever SEEN one real cotton gray belt and that’s the one I own.

Here’s a comparison of a real gray belt, khaki belt and then the khaki belts AJ sells:

I also believe you have to think about them within the context of the film(the uniforms). These were three guys going into business on the cheap. They got their uniforms out of some surplus store. What was available at the time? Gray flightsuits and belts? I doubt it.

If you think of it that way, there’s no need for the costume department to CUSTOM DYE the suits and belts to be gray when the characters in the film wouldn’t have done it themselves. Why would they?

Only problem is…OD#3 is khaki when talking about the belts and other equipment.

From this page: http://www.atthefront.com/khaki.htm

and

Hope that clarifies some confusion. Perhaps purchasing a reproduction belt, and washing/bleaching it (diluted solution) or leaving it in the sun might “age” it to the GB “correct” color?

unfortunately, it’s an almost impossible question to answer.

  1. Military uniforms and field gear were made by different companies

  2. Their dyes all varied in shade by degrees, even though the war department set a standard.

  3. Some used items that are sold have been faded badly, others are unused surplus still in original condition. It only takes a small amount of time to take a piece of field gear, expose it to the elements and turn it from olive drab to complete khaki(and all the levels in between). This is why a soldier might have new, dark o.d. trousers, but an old khaki haversack or musette bag that’s only a couple months old.

  4. perhaps the items were washed, or dyed to alter them.

It’s all speculation as to which of these apply to create the color of the belts used onscreen. There are too many factors to really come anywhere close to certain.

Slimer you misunderstand what they are saying. Also I summed that up in the post.

They are not saying there is no Khaki or that OD#3 is simply Khaki. There IS a Khaki but what most people often refer to now in the reproductions, faded used ones, and even in the true originals as Khaki was OD#3 but as seen in the comparison pictures there was a dark “khaki”. Also that link talks about the Uniforms more then anything not pistol belts and web accessories.

As the conclusion said and as Austin said they were more then likely the reproductions. More then likely they were one of these light Khaki’s or discolored OD#3.

Actually, Spooky, I think you misunderstand.

You list 4 options in your original post: White, Grey, Khaki, or “secret option number 4”…OD#3.

The fact of the matter is that…when discussing WW2 equipment, which this pistol belt is, OD#3 is Khaki…or vice versa. The only “official khaki” according to the QM of the time was the summer uniform. All else is listed as OD#3.

Khaki is simply the “word in common usage” to describe OD#3, same as green is used to describe OD#7.

Again…a quote from the link I posted…

*Emphasis added.

sigh This isn’t just discussing original colors. No I do not misunderstand

They have made actual Khaki’s (such as the deeper ones in GB2), then and now. The 4th option is in there in the sense of maybe the reason we see this gray is because they could have found reproductions or original OD#3. The discrepancies come from what is properly labeled between the two, the conclusion was it was definitely a reproduction probably more of the ones labeled Khaki that have the lighter beige color (maybe having allusions to the OD#3.)

The third belt down looks best to me, BUT…

…it doesn’t look like any khaki pistol belt I’ve ever seen. It’s much less brown. And it’d be much easier to get a white belt to be that color.

In fact, now that I’ve seen this, I think I’ll take my white belt which I dipped briefly in gray dye and rub some fuller’s earth into it to give it more of a tan color. I can see from these photos that more grey dye to get it a bit darker would probably give it too much of a bluish tint.

The third belt down looks just like the last three pictures I posted

No it doesn’t. The last three pictures you posted don’t even look like the last three pictures you posted. Every one of those belts is a different color in the pic:

Of course the different lighting conditions don’t help any:

Khaki, white, bluish gray:

Khaki, beige, neutral gray:

Here is the above image color corrected, under the assumption that the upper left is supposed to be white:

Under these conditions I think I now like the middle one best, but it doesn’t really matter. It’s obvious that the color will look vastly different under different lighting conditions, and as we have no way of knowing how the originals were lit, arguing about the specific shade of khaki is futile.

I’m just gonna adjust the color of my belt till I think it looks good in photos next to my suit. :slight_smile:

great post spooky, you really “belted” it out of the park…that is to say, you hit a home run.

What’s with posts now being uneditable after a little while?

In order to use that feature, you have to tell AJ he has a cute butt. :grin:

Maybe actually try taking lighting and picture contrast into consideration. You can’t crop photos over another photo under completely different conditions and quality and say they look nothing alike. As Austin pointed out his photos show different shades in each photo even.

But I will take back that the OD#3 is a good match in general though…others Austin posted and some of the shades…hmm

How can you take lighting into consideration when you have no color reference in the image?

And you can’t post photos of several belts taken in vastly different lighting conditions with no reference for color, and say they’re all the same color.

Everyone might wanna check the new picture of billy murray put up in the photo’s section of ghostbusters.com. It seems (with the lighting) that the blue belt might actually be the closest one! I’d post a pic but I don’t know how to link it from flash.

And just for S&G: Ray’s belt

Oh wow someone contributed! No moronic arguments!!

The first picture does have some blue in it that is for sure. We need to get some blu-ray captures in this joint.