The Receptionists of the Ghostbusters

So, this topic is not here to offend anyone or undermine anyone’s opinion of the 2016 reboot. This topic is specifically here to compare the first line of defense of the respective Ghostbuster franchise(s). Kevin and Janine, or secretaries in general have, perhaps, the toughest job in the business. They deal with the initial call, the fear or apprehension of the person on the other end of the phone. Much like a 9-11 dispatcher, these people have the responsibility of screening the call that informs the professionals that go out into the field, and deal with whatever the problem actually is. I caution all who read this to actually understand that fact. These people are entrusted with the highest level of responsibility. These people have to have the impartiality to differentiate between fearful babble and actual concrete evidence, or the occasional schizo nutball off the streets.

I feel it an important point to say that I am only comparing the original film to the reboot. I am completely ignoring GBII, RGB, EGB, and the comic books when speaking of Janine. I am only comparing the original character of Janine to the original character of Kevin.

We start with Janine Melnitz. Janine is tough as nails, highly intellectual portrayal of a working class woman of New York. We are first introduced to Janine with no backstory. Just that she has taken on the role of receptionist for the Ghostbusters. She is obviously highly intelligent, albeit a bit taken with Egon based upon the initial conversation she has with Egon. She is then belittled by Venkman, only to later question Venkman on work hours and (may be a stretch) ethics. Thus proving her strength and knowledge of the business at hand. We than see Janine, delighted with glee hit her buzzer when the first real call for the team comes in. Later on, after Peck’s second intrusion into the firehouse Janine goes to bat for the Ghostbusters. Saying something to the effect of “Oh no, I know you need a warrant!”. She goes as far as to follow Peck, the NYPD, and Con-Ed into the basement and alert Egon to their nefarious plans. She not only shows her love (despite horrible hours) for the job she holds., but also an understanding of law and procedure, I get the feeling that Janine hates her job but understands the importance of the service the Ghostbusters are providing. She is knowledgeable, competent and well informed, as we also see to a much lesser extent in the montage.

We then go to Kevin. Kevin’s character isn’t even dignified with a last name, as I feel to be indicative of the character in general. Kevin cannot differentiate between the basic human senses, doesn’t know how a phone works, is completely aloof, is more concerned with his headshots than doing a good job, has absolutely zero knowledge of the service the Ghostbusters are looking to provide, and feels the need to “move in” with the Ghostbusters, indicating his general helplessness. We are first introduced to Kevin on his initial job interview. We are given a bit of insight into the his past, unlike Janine. Kevin informs the team and the general audience of his incompetence and past failures, and general lack of direction. Quite opposite to Janine’s relationship with Egon, we see Erin (and Holtzmann to an extent) take a sexually driven liking to Kevin, thus, he is objectified and hired, having relatively no bearing on ability or qualification. Kevin continues to show his incompetence through various indicators. When challenged with a loud noise, he covers his eyes as opposed to his ears. He doesn’t know how the phones work, doesn’t fully grasp the service the Ghostbusters are trying to provide and moronically refers to the first call as a “goat” problem. He than proceeds to profess his desire to become a Ghostbuster in a rather childish manner, subsequently becoming possessed. During the climax, this point is further driven home by Abby saying something to the effect of “he was just starting to get the phones!” which also reminds me of a point in the film where the Ghostbusters make a comment about disconnecting his phone because he “won’t know the difference”. After the climax of the film, Kevin’s aloof presence and lack of compassion are driven home even more based on the fact that presumably while the world was in it’s darkest hour, he found the time to grab himself a sandwich. In spite of this he than doubles down on his desire to become a Ghostbuster.

I find it also important to address Louis Tully, as it was brought to my attention the Kevin also mirrors the relative helplessness and buffonary of Louis. Yes, Louis continuously locks himself out if his apartment, is socially awkward, and bears all of the indicators of a total nerd. This being said, Louis shows his business first attitude by making his party a business expense, offering to be the Ghostbusters accountant, and earlier in the film expressing his interest in healthy eating and fitness.

Now, in both (all three) instances I’m sure I’m leaving out some minor details. Though I think I’ve hit the generalities and persona of each character respectively. Janine compared to Kevin, in my opinion, shows the pulse of contrast to these two films. While one is shown as a competent yet undervalued member, the other is shown as a necessary beast of burden, only in place because of looks and desire.

I think this stark contrast is an overlooked indicator to what these two films actually are and the underlying message of each. I leave it to everyone who cares to contribute to this particular topic to discuss this in a well thought out and rational manner.

Again, I feel it important to make the point that I did enjoy the reboot (I have now seen it in theaters 3 times) but I obviously have had my issues with it. I really can’t wait for the DVD release with deleted scenes, so I can get a true analysis on the things I’ve taken issues with.

At this point, I feel as though these two characters are the only two who can be fairly compared. I also, as previously stated, feel these two characters are the only two, based on profession, that can be closely compared.

Right, like I said, he’s an actor. Seriously, it’s not that much of a stretch. :wink:

Kevin drove me nuts. Greatly disliked the character, although my boyfriend found him funny. They could have done a much better job with the receptionist character. I loved Janine, she was fantastic.

I wouldn’t call Janine highly intelligent. When Peck walks into the building, she tries to bluff him with her JD from the Law School of TV. That’s not even a good delaying tactic.

Kevin is a hit and a miss at the same time for me. Some lines I love, some jokes I crinched at. He feels like he initially meant to be a cross between Tully and Janine, but Hemsworth dumbed him down even more, according to the interviews, and they rolled with it.

I’m OK with the difference though: it would be to easy just to copy paste the same character.

She’s a bit, you know, spacey.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BRiBlBe17SY

You summed up Janine’s character nicely, and showed some of the brilliance of the first film. She takes Ghostbusting seriously, which helps make it believable, which is an important part of why the film is still so endeared.

Personally I like stupid characters (probably because I can identify with them easier,) but since I haven’t gotten a chance to see the reboot I can’t really comment much on Kevin. All I know is that his featurette to date has gotten the most laughs out of me out of all of the rest of the reboot’s promotional material. I like those kinds of characters a lot, for instance Kelly Bundy (Married… with Children,) and Lowell Mather (Wings,) is my favorites on both shows. Hitchcock and Skully (Brooklyn Nine-Nine) and Harry Solomon (3rd Rock from the Sun) never fail to get a laugh out of me, same goes for Beavis and Butthead.

I understand that some of you believe there is/could be an agenda behind his stupidity, which is fine. If that is true (and he was written with a political agenda) I don’t find it a reason to dislike the character, but rather the people who wrote the character. But seeing as Hemsworth improvised a lot, I believe the only agenda was an agenda to be funny.

In Kevin’s defense, his team did get to the semifinals of a hide-and-seek tournament.

I’m begging to get the feeling you’re a famous actress using these forums as an outlet valve :wink:

See, I found him hilarious too. The dude has some serious acting chops and has a great inclination for humor. He was a riot in the first Thor. But, seeing beyond the actor and strictly focusing on the character, he drove me nuts too.

Maybe highly intelligent is a slight exaggeration, but the fact that she has the intuition to bluff him, is more proof of her strength and ability to think on her feet. Kevin would have just dopely let Peck in.

Yeah, it’s easy for a super handsome monster of a man to have no problem dumbing down the only main male character in the movie ;-).

Do you know any 9-11 dispatchers? They’re some of the most on edge stressed out people I know. Or anyone who works in Human Resources? It’s all behind the scenes dealing with the daily complaints. You get none of the glory and all of the BS.

Oh, dude he’s absolutely hilarious, I’m also a big fan of Hemmsworth. I also identify with the “stoner/idiot” in movies a lot more than I do a boy scout Dudley Do-Right type character.

I agree completely, I take little to no issue with Hemmsworth, he wanted to make the character funny and succeeded (if you subscribe to the idea that he improvised a lot of his scenes and lines. I’m not claiming there to be a political agenda behind the character, I’m merely comparing the two characters.

If anything, I get the idea of “You know what would be funny? All the heroic handsome men are super smart. You know what would be really funny? Make him a complete and total idiot! Bringing a stark contrast to our strong female leads!” or something along those lines.

I got the “most improved bowler” award two years in a row. It was a church league and the majority of my competition were senior citizens. Where’s my damn defense!?!? :whatever:

Heh, if only. I’ve just done some little plays in NYC and might have encountered similar people, hehe. But thank you.

Ahh that’s okay. You can catch my small screen debut at the end of the month on Spike’s Ink Master! I’m sure I’ll grab a total of .5 seconds of screen time. My forearm is going to be famous!

Fine, I’ll be the blunt jerk.

Janine takes her job seriously and does her job accordingly, and has great character interaction with attitude.

Kevin is an idiot that was hired based on his looks and doesn’t know how to answer a phone until he’s told to.

You can’t compare the two.

That’s awesome, congrats!

Exactly my point!

Chris Hemsworth did such a great job playing it straight compared to everyone else the problem seemed to be like he walked on set from another movie.

Here’s what saves Kevin for me. We can all agree Erin is being a little too forward in their affections. They could have easily made Kevin obliviously cool with it, and it would have been downright creepy! But no, during the little dance number Kevin is pretty obviously turned off by her attentions. That little moment actually gives him some dignity for me. :wink:

I love it when Yates is like “Ew…you’re all sweaty.”

I honestly think Janine would roast Kevin alive for his utter incompetence. As much as Dr. Venkman annoys her with his antics, Kevin’s inability to perform the job, even on a basic level, would infuriate her to the point where she’d throw him out of the chair to perform some clean-up, simply to preserve her sanity. :eyeroll:

I would submit that Kevin is more exemplary of a typical employee now and Janine is an exemplar of an employee in the eighties. Having recently gone through the process of hiring staff, it’s fairly clear to me there is a significant generational divide amongst workers.

Beyond the above observation, I think it’s fair to compare the two from a work function analysis but not so much as characters. I didn’t get the vibe any character was meant to be a direct correlation to a prior character. Kevin is a mishmash of several traits we saw in GB1&2. They fit different roles.

Also, I generally agree secretaries do not get enough credit for their jobs.