What do you want in a GB comic?

I agree. I hate that I feel obligated to keep buying the book knowing it’s terrible, but I want to support the property. I suppose it couldn’t hurt to provide a link at IDW. There’s been one or two new posts since I jumped over there, but not much activity…I suppose we’ll just have to hope they follow the link and take a look at our concerns…

I would like to see a, straight up, honest adaptation of the movies, taking from where the seconed left off. and not where they die and fight mobsters.

Ok. Everything that I could and could not think of has already been posted in this thread. Keep at it guys!

I want to see a stand alone, character based issue with Ray and Peter doing an overnight job at a run of the mill haunted house in the suburbs. Nothing world threatening, life threatening, . . . just something that lets a writer have a little fun with two great characters.

you might get that if there is ever a comic adaptation of the game (which is set after the secound movie), and about the other side… i agree. in a comic i would like to see them alive and fighting supernatural villans… with the packs… over them being dead and dealing with mobster ghosts who think that “gozer and vigo were prima ballerina’s” compared to them (taken from a developing article)

on a side note: Those gangster ghosts must be either arrogant or on something. Gozer could wup their ectoplasmic buts by just waving his/her hands.

I’d like to see a Ghostbusters comic that starts as modest as Ghostbusters can be and dosn’t jump into a stupid ass story line about being dead with Mobsters or travelling in time. So far everything IDW has done reads like a bad fan fiction.

okay, i have to voice against some peoples opinions i found on proton charging.

i found one complaing about the time travel concept (saying it would be a failure like tmnt 3) and another saying that this could be as bad as “those god awful NOW RGB comics”.

i know everyone is entitled to their opinion, but these i really dont get.

The Now RGB comics were good in my opinion. how can GB fans anywhere not like it?

Time travel is cool, thats the main reason i like TMNT 3 (the sacred sands of time scepter is cool, and GET THIS: it is in the comics!) i really will never understand all the negativity to that film… and i dont want it explained because its always the same answers.

i’m giving this comic a chance, i wouldnt mind if it was ONLY in new york but i can be flexible. its being written by a fan.

not someone who had no love for the series like champange (never again). now thats saying something.

P.S, any negatives will be pointless, i’ve said what i wanted with this topic so i’m done. gone to other topics.

this is maybe a little unrelated, but i noticed a lot of people saying how they liked the art from the Legion series. Well I am fortunate enough to have Steve Kurth the artist who drew that series living in Eau Claire, Wisconsin with me. I have met him several times and he has critiqued my comic pages as well (I am an illustration student), he’s a cool guy and nice as hell too. and if you think his ghostbusters stuff is good, you should see his ultimate iron man pages for marvel, they are off the hook!

Can anyone explain why TMNT3 is being held up as the example of time travel storytelling here?

Stop trying to improve Ghostbusters! You can’t do it, IDW, so just stop it! Stop redesigning equipment, adding new Ghostbusters, and introducing Gozer’s wacky relatives.

Here’s what I want to see: a 12 issue story, about four guys, all friends and equals, out busting ghosts, night after night. They drink, they smoke, there’s occasional group tensions, and they have trouble with the city administration, but they get the job done. But they’re getting tired, worn down by the constant onslaught of ghosts. And all the while, something evil is growing under the city.

When you’ve done that story successfully, you can build other stories from there.

It’s simple. It’s an easy story to tell. The problem, as I see it, is that IDW doesn’t want to stray too far from the source and ■■■■ off fans. Understandable, but they’re going about it all wrong.

Fighting Gozer’s father with all-new redesigned proton packs is BAD.

Fighting an all-new ghost with the classic gear is GOOD.

That’s a simple as I can make it.

EDIT: Pretty much the defining moment for what the Ghostbusters lives should be like is when Ray and Peter are returning to the firehouse, smoking, tired, carrying used traps, and Peter tells Ray, “You don’t look good. You’ve looked better. You didn’t used to look like this.” and then they hire Winston on the spot.

as of yet I’ve not seen any GB comics that I’ve enjoyed, be it the old Now! comics RGB series, the 88MPH series, or the current IDW series. The thing that strikes me about all of these attempts is that no one has ever truly captured the “voices” of the ghostbusters. Venkman never feels like Venkman. He feels like a stereotypical wiseass. Ray never feels like Ray, especially what 88MPH did to him (cheer up Emo Ray). Well, you get the idea.

The most important thing to me is the characters. If I believe that I’m reading the characters, if I buy the dialogue coming from them, you’re 80% of the way there. I like RGB, but I’d want to steer clear of intelligent ghosts a bit more. I have no problem with intelligent spooks, but the movies made it clear that such spectres weren’t the norm. The whole time travel angle and other side angle just doesn’t fit Ghostbusters as far as I’m concerned. They feel forced and contrived and more than a little cliched. There’s plenty for the GBs to do in the real world without coming out with outlandish ways to throw them into the old west, or killing them physically so they can bomb around the netherworld.

Art wise, I’ve never been happy with any of the GB comics past or present. I understand that likeness rights are an issue, that’s fair enough. Personally, I find the gritty realistic style that IDW has been cultivating to be, well, really ugly. I don’t like looking at the pages. I don’t like the character designs. I find it all highly unappealing. I personally favour a more stylized, slightly cartoonish approach, like what Dapper Dan has done. This is just my personal preference of course, to each their own. I just feel the slightly more cartoonish look lends itself better to both the comedy and the horror aspects. The dichotomy between the playful/cartoonish style and the horrific of ghouls and demons I think is particularly effective visually speaking.

I certainly have no problem with revisiting some of the more interesting ghouls of the RGB universe, the Grundel, the boogeyman, Sam Hain and the like. Pleny of interesting stories to explore there. But I lean more towards the tone of the live action films than the animated series, as much as I loved it.

I want to see perfect actor/character likenesses (nothing cartoonish or caricature), accurate equipment and stories born from the movies and maybe some redone stories from RGB (intense ones like Ragnorok and Roll). AND… stories that include GB II events! Why is the second film never used in any comic cannon? Some will say because it was bad but the game developers didn’t think that way and neither did Dan and Harold so let’s not give that reason.

Hey, just bumping this thread back up to the top because I was noticing alot of people (and even a couple of IDW GB creators here on the boards) in the “Halloween Special” thread starting to discuss what sorts of things people wanted in writng and art from a GB comic. It reminded me of this. I would think alot of the stuff mentioned here still stands. I feel like alot of the ideas bounced around between myself, slimer28, and Spengs on the first page would still make for some great GB comic moments. It keeps the classic feel of things, blends in a few cartoon and video game sensibilities, and tells new stories, while still keeping things firmly rooted in the world of the first 2 movies.

So Dapper Dan, Mr. Beard, and any other creators involved with the IDW books, feel free to check it out, and everybody feel free to add to this. As someone who is a fan of Ghostbusters and aspires to be a comic creator one day (and in a perfect world, work on a GB comic, movie, or tv show), I enjoy seeing people’s thoughts on where they’d like to see the world of GB go.

:smiley:

PS

I haven’t had a chance to read Convolution or the Halloween issue yet. I went to the local comic shop this past weekend and they told me I’d have to wait for the holiday trade that comes out next month. As far as the stuff that has come before that, I’ve had my little nit picks about certain aspects, but I think I’m in the same general boat as everyone else. “The Other Side” was a stinker, “Displaced Aggression” was an improvement, but still didn’t fully grasp things. The Christmas special rubbed me the wrong way personally, with how the characters interacted. The Valentine’s Day issue was the only one so far that I thought actually got closest to what I’d like to see to some degree in a GB book. There were some things that could have been better, but for the confines of a one-shot, I thought they pulled it off as best as could be done. Plus they gave Winston some face time where as most stories seem to want to keep him in the background.

It seems as though each of the stories (out of what I’ve read, not counting the Halloweeen and Comic con issues) relies on what was cleverly reffered to as a “big twinkie” in Dapper Dan’s comic pitch. Some bigger-than-average situation that forces the GBs into a new and different way of reacting. Now it’s one thing to tell new and fresh stories, but it doesn’t neccessarily mean that you have to jump to something drastically different.

In TOS, it was “THE GBs ARE DEAD!”

In Displaced Agression it was “THE GBs ARE TRAPPED IN TIME AND FIGHTING GOZER’S DAD!”

Even in the Valentine’s day issue, it was that they had to build all new equipment to not tear up the lady’s apartment when they busted the ghost. Now, granted it made sense within the storyline, but on the whole it seemed kinda like the old Batman movies, where he would start the next movie with a different suit every time just because. It felt like an excuse to show off shiny new toys.

Maybe it would be more beneficial to not be so ambitious about setting up a new, big, awesome, powerful entity and all the back story that comes with it, or building a story around being able to show off some new, shiny equipment, and just start off with a simple exposition: GBs get back from a call. It’s late evening. They’re tired. They can’t wait to sleep. Just as they hit the hay, they get a call. They briefly contemplate telling the customer they will come in the morning, but Janine says it’s a little girl. Begrudgingly they get back up. Peter makes cracks about how this little girl better have rich parents or be getting huge allowances.

We see how Ray interacts with the child and how that side of his personality comes out. Some aspect of each character’s personality and how they interact with each other and how they do their job and how it affects people has a chance to have the spotlight in the story, even if it’s just for a few panels or a page. Egon uncovers something startling. There’s a twist. The girl is actually the ghost. It’s a trap! Winston engages his no nonsense- “AWWW HELL NO, TRYIN’ TO BATTLE MY BOYS?! THAT AIN’T LEGAL! LET’S BLAST IT!” mode. They take down the ghost/ghosts. Finally, a final quip from Peter about “So… I guess we’re not getting paid.” As they drive home.

There’s a decent one shot right there. Granted, it doesn’t pertain to a specific holiday as written. With some modification it might be able to. But the thing is that it stands on it’s own as a solid example of a GB story and let’s the characters do what they do best as only each one of them can do it, without relying on new equipment or a huge life threatening entity/ordeal to push the story in lieu of character development.

Now, no one is saying there can’t be new equipment or new major bad guys, but give the charcters and the story room to breathe and establish the status quo before the s*** hits the fan. Let’s see the guys do their day to day job and build up to an intense situation.

Unfortunately, if IDW keeps confining the stories to one shots and 4 issue minis, it’s extremely difficult to do that. They need to at least test the waters. Try a 6 issue mini. Let the story breathe a little more. If that works out once or twice, try a 12 issue, year long story arch, then follow it up with a couple completely unrelated one shots. Ease into trying longer stories. Try 2 12 issue archs back to back. If it works out, then hey, that’s pretty much the beginnings of an ongoing right there. There’s nothing saying you can’t do a 12, then a 6 and two 4s, maybe some one shots inbetween.

The point is that IDW’s GB books thus far tend to whip out a “big twinkie” as the catalyst to tell the story, and because of the constricted space for telling the story, it feels kind of forced. There need to be paranormal threats, absolutely, and definitely there should be new equipment being developed and used, but not at the expense of losing the core of the story, which is 4 guys who run a company that specializes in paranormal investigations and elimenations. They’re ghost cops. Not everyday is a homicidal maniac or a hostage situation or a mass jail break or a shoot out with the mob. Sometimes cops have to deal with generic day to day things, like parking tickets, break ins, robberies, heck, even paperwork. Doesn’t mean you can’ t pull a great story out of those generic things though if you come at it from the right angle or a unique perspective or add a little twist.

Same thing with GB.

That’s my 2 cents in addition to what I mentioned on the first page of the thread anyway. Take it for what it’s worth.

Hope you like Con-Volution, Jack :wink:

Jim!

The rule of thumb when writing Ghostbusters and anything really. “The right people will get this”- Joel Hodgeson.

I think if you want to write a good Ghostbusters tale and it being true to what HArold and Dan wrote you have to do one thing. Understand Dan’s view of the afterlife and have some knowledge of Parapsychology. Dan doesn’t operate on the idea of the afterlife as is held in a classic Christian sense (it’s why the Other Side failed so miserably because it was so rooted in the idea of a Christian afterlife and it stuck out like a sore thumb).

Dan seems to be working from the notion of different dimensions producing ghosts in one sense (in terms of Gozer, Slimer, non humanoid looking vapors and apparitions, but also the parapsychological idea of the power of the mind. A mind with a strong enough will can survive death and still be cognizant to a point. And even has the power to try to reconstitute it’s body. ( Library ghost comes to mind). You have to write from that sort of scientific background that Dan wrote from.

The artwork should pop. I haven’t really seen good artwork since Legion. And I have to say aside from all the obvious management issues with 88mph, there GB series was the best I have read in a long run. The best IDW title that I have read that really seemed to show potential was Past, Present, and Future. A realy nice take on A Christmas Carol with a nice little twist.

Secondly, have a grasp on each character. What is Peter, what is Ray, what is Egon, what is Winston. How do they co-exist, flesh them out but keep them true to the characters as we know them.

Ultimately, stay away from RGB. RGB has it’s place and it was on Saturday morning and in the hearts of little Ghostbusters. Give us stories that are funny, scary, and more than just a one note sales pitch. By this I mean, don’t write this as if it’s for kids and don’t draw the characters as if they are in the RGB version again.

I love the art that hints at the actors without it being an exact likeness. The comics should be rooted in the movies and not in DIC universe. But remember one thing, the best stories the RGB show told were the ones in the first three seasons, when it was dark and the humor stood out more because of it. The Grundel, SamHain, the characters that were real threats can be touched on again with a more adult bent.

I want to see a writer who actually wants to write for the property and not just get a paycheck. We need a writer with passion who will take the time to flesh out the characters and research some of the themes of the afterlife, talk to Dan and find out how he envisioned the hereafter and where the ghosts, Gods, and goblins come from. And after all that, make the story your own but rooted in what Ghostbusters were and are.

I say writer but what they really need is an editor who really cares. So I say IDW hire, Peter David, J. Michael, or even Dan Ackroyd himself to oversee the direction of the book. Someone who will try to have the best story put out in the vein of Ghostbusters.

However, the problem with the current comic series is they are all one shots and there is only so much you can do in 22 pages plus there doesn’t seem to be one unified vision/ editor on this property.

The biggest problem that I see isn’t individual storyline it’s there hasn’t been a real reestablishment/ reintroduction of the characters and series. They started out with the horrible TOS which seems more like a story with the GB character just sort of inserted rather than a true GB story.

They followed with “Displaced Aggression” which would be a good tale if it was issue number 5 in an ongoing series. Out of all the titles so far they haven’t been bad (TOS the exception) they just needed to follow a story that reintroduces the characters and set up the IDW GB universe.

■■■■■■■■■■■■, Convolution, What in Sam Hain, all play on the overall premise and come up with a different take on how to bust a ghost, which in itself is good and clever but only works after you have established the convention of actually busting ghosts and set up that rhythm.

Right now there putting the ECtO-1 before the motor and playing off the idea that these are continuing off of the movies and RGB series and so they don’t need to reintroduce the characters or set up the storyline, setting, plot, etc. Which is an interesting idea however, this isn’t a third movie or sequel to RGB, this is the first comic titles since Legion six years ago and since the Marvel issues 20 years before that. The comic continuity has to be it’s own continuity for it to work. And comics are a different medium then TV and film and I for 1 can’t help but seperate the different format into a different timeline/ universe/ what have you. So they need to establish this IDW universe.

Everyone knows the Transformers storyline from G1 but IDW reintroduced the characters and situations and gave them new twists and turns to update them for the current time. Same with the GI Joe franchise. The only franchise they haven’t done that for is Ghostbusters and it shows with a bunch of decent stories that stick out because there is no cohesion between books in terms of characterization, artwork, etc. And no attempt to do so. There doesn’t seem to be a Ghostbusters bible that establishes this is who Egon is, who Ray is, etc. This is what they do and the world they live in. And without that that series will fall short of what it could be because each writer will have their own take on what Ghostbusters is. They need to re-establish this universe and these characters for the IDW titles. They can’t just keep releasing the titles as they are. They’re good, but without any sort of context there just one off cash ins that insult us (unintentional though it may be) the fan.

Ghostbusters is a property that should be treated as respectful as Transformers and GI Joe and it’s not being.