What would've happened if Peck was allowed to see the Grid?

In the ■■■■■■■ match that occurs between Dr. Venkman and Peck, I’ve wondered since childhood if the disaster with the Grid could have been averted?

Obviously the shouting match that happened in Venkman’s office was the result of the two abrasive personalities clashing. But let’s say for instance, Stanz had the office upstairs and handled more of the business-end of the Ghostbusters. Or, Venkman had been more convienial, and had humored Peck and actually showed him the Grid.

Let’s examine first, Peck’s interest in the Ghostbusters. “Frankly, there’s been a lot of wild stories in the media and we want to assess, any possible, environmental impact from your operation.” - Says it in a nutshell. His perserverance on this ideal is an obvious foolhardy attempt to climb the ladder at the EPA, rather than an environmentally conscious, and ethically obligated investigation into the Ghostbusters.

But I think that Venkman might have shown him the grid if Peck hadn’t been such a jerk…OR he wouldn’t have shown him at all, to protect the tech that makes Ghostbusting possible. But part of me thinks, once Peck got down there into the basement, he would immediately might’ve spotted something wrong - anything nuclear or laser operated would’ve been a red flag - and thus subject to more scrutiny, which might have produced the same results - a shutting down of the constainment system ultimately.

We all know of course, that the Ecto-Containment system isn’t nuclear - but rather, it utilizes an electrically powered laser orientated mode of storage via an algorithim on the atomic level, devised by Dr. Stanz and Dr. Spengler. But perhaps the use of lasers in this way, (by Cold War-era early 1980’s EPA standards) an egregious no-no.

But this points to the overall unmentioned secrecy surrounding the Ghostbusters technology. I’m sure they never applied for patents, as the Ghostbusters proton packs are basically unlicensed nuclear accelerators. So in this regard, I think they are operating outside the law. After the defeat of Gozer, the 5 year long fall-out thereafter, court proceedings, and the subsequent lifting of the judicial restrainment order, Ghostbusting’s science demonstrated itself as a useful defensive technology that was allowed certain concessions, later operating within the bureaucratic and generally ignored regulatory policies of PCOC.

But in 1984, I’m sure Stanz, Venkman, and Spengler were leery of Governmental regulatory oversights, as Ghostbusting at this point, was just an advanced form of pest-control. So in general, I think that if the heated argument between Peck and Venkman had not taken place, the EPA would have assuredly found something wrong, and shut them down, OR another government agency would’ve swooped in and done something similar. Ghostbusting, as a business, with the technology required of it, couldn’t have survived for long in the 1980’s without some sort of government intervention.

I think if they allowed Peck to see it right then and there, it would just be more evidence for him to get a warrant to shut it down anyways. Peck went in there to ensure something was wrong, in fact, if he went to see everything before the warrant, it probably would of made it worse, because he would of came back with people to confinscate stuff and then shut down the grid, causing explosion. That is what I see would of happened anyways.

i have a question for after the grid was shut off. once all the ghost were let free again, who went out to catch them all again? thus Slimer was released for GB2. they never show that and then for GB2 at the beginning they are all wash outs so obviously people forgot about it all after the roof top incident. HMM

Yes, it truly strikes me as an inevitable event. Look into that even more, Vinz Clortho talked about prophesized “sign” - which I’m sure was conjured thousands if not hundreds of thousands of years ago by Sumerian priests/shamans. The “sign” being, an absolute near-apocolyptic surge of PKE from the shutting down of the grid, and the ghosts running rampant thereafter.

Look at it this way - think of Dana’s building as a pulsing antenna. As the pulse gets stronger, it generates more PKE to open the portal to Gozer’s dimension so he can destroy the world. A by-product of the surge of PKE is obviously materialization of more and more ghosts. Once the portal was closed, most of the ghosts probably dissipated or went dormant… and were re-summoned and began appearing again in 1988 - (sort of like disturbing a bee’s nest)powered by the psychomagnetheric slime flow in the Pneumatic transit system, below ground. So your answer is - in 1984 the freed ghosts mostly went away after the defeat of Gozer. Then in 1988, Vigo’s painting arrived in New York, began to feed off the negative energy there, generating a slime flow, and then materializing the ghosts. Hope that answers your question.

I contemplated the same thing for quite a few years now. What if Pete had been nice enough to show Peck the grid and I always come back to the same conclusion, Peck would’ve shut them down anyways. I’m glad to see I’m not the only one that sees Peck as the manipulative little ■■■■■ that he is :walterpeck:

Very good explanation of the lack of ghosts Bennyboombatz, I never thought of it that way. :cool:

He’s a government worker and would have shut it down anyways, unless they handed it over to the EPA so the government could take over, and as with any government controlled institution, would end up an a disaster.

So all in all, the story wouldn’t change much, a meltdown would happen, just a bit later in time. And the Ghostbusters would STILL be held responsible for it.