I did this so you don’t have to learn the hard way. I nearly destroyed my Stay Puft at one point, but I knew it would happen and I was prepared beforehand to fix it…
So last week, I set out to correct the awful yellowing on my Stay Puft. let me detail the process for those that want to do this too. Let me start by saying that you cannot remove the yellowing itself. It IS the paint. It has to stay that way. None of the peroxide de-yellow procedures will work with him, as he is not plastic and the foam can become damaged.
The only process is to spray the figure. Unfortunately, regular spray paints will cause pore expansion and cracks in the foam. Besides that, the paint will crack and shatter off if you press on the foam. You cannot simply spraypaint him white again.
As a test, the first thing I did was spray him with Army Painter products. They’re intended for use with gaming miniatures and they generally don’t melt plastics. In this case, they went on beautifully. As you can see here, I used a white base coat, sprayed blue on the lowered regions, then went back over it with white. The end result looked great, but the moment you press on the foam or move it, it begins to crack and fall off. No-go, no chance.
Looked great until I pushed on it and the paint start falling off in large flakes.
It was at this point that I had an idea. I needed a spray-on product that didn’t create a shell-like surface. It needed to be flexible. For that, I went with **Plasti-Dip. **I bought a can of white plasti-dip at Lowes and went to town. This works wonderfully to create a buffer. Some of you will be satisfied with just a plasti-dip paint coat, but I wanted to go further with it. The plasti-dip itself isn’t pure white and I didn’t like the lack of blue tint.
For this next OPTIIONAL step, you do risk damaging the Stay Puft in minor ways. I wanted my Stay Puft to resemble the Neca product, with the grain texture and blue tones. Unfortunately, through my experiments, I did have some pore expansion on the toy.and cracking in the joints of the folds. The enamel paints from earlier had left little pock marks on the foam. Those were easy to correct. **Just take some DAP(caulking in a tube) and wet your fingers and spread it onto the pock marks like butter. **Let it dry, and the problem is taken care of.
With the DAP now dry and the toy smooth again, I sprayed it over with a layer of Plasti-Dip. Spray at 50% coating and let it dry for about 10 minutes between coats. After four coats, I hit it with Rustoleum texture spray, which matches Neca’s product perfectly.
Afterward, **I gave it several more coats of Plasti-Dip to create that flexible rubber buffer that it needs to avoid cracking when you push on the foam. **
From there, I took the Army Painter blue and once again sprayed in the lowered areas, then I went back over the raised areas with flat white Army Painter spray and let it set.
So the process is to coat the figure in white plasti-dip spray before you attempt any actual spray-painting. The plasti-dip will allow the coat to flex with the foam and not split or crack off. Apply it in THIN coats. The Rustoleum texture spray is totally optional.
One HUGE warning. When you tape off the figure, be very careful with what tape you use. I used blue-line painters tape and it actually tore at the foam when I peeled it off. I had better luck with white painter’s tape and tamiya tape. The foam Matty used really is cheap as dog sh*t.
And again, always apply the plasti-dip in really thin coats. If the spray builds up, it tends to leave a sort of bubbly look. Be patient with it.





