Lucky and Trevor’s parts need to be cut to the bare bones. Melody’s actor needs to do a 30s to 50s new York accent. Unique ghosts fleeing when the containment unit breaks open. Include a montage Behind the scenes film in NYC with the actors!
They didn’t already?
I’d cut the Slimer and Trevor scenes, the fight with the possessor on the second floor of the firehouse and remove Lucky’s from the scene in Nadeems apartment. I’d rather focus on Lars, he was a more interesting side character than Trevor and Lucky.
Some great suggestions in here and I can’t remember what my original changes were that inspired the thread.
Firstly, I love Frozen Empire as it is. That said it clearly didn’t hit for all fans / critics, and there are glaring areas for improvement. These are changes I agree with or would’ve made.
-
I agree with giving Lars’ role at the PRC to Lucky, with Lars supervising but taking a back seat… then give Hubert’s exposition role at the Library to Lars. Patton is great but unless they have a plan for him as a future cast member he isn’t needed here. Although he does flesh out the idea Ray has pals in the city, which is a nice bit of world building tbf.
-
Montage. When Phoebe gets benched and the others get called out… we need a montage to show Phoebe, Podcast and Ray bored around the firehouse intercut with Gary and Callie busting 3-4 ghosts. This ticks several boxes missing from the movie and injects some brief action.
-
Phoebe investigating the Melody Diner fire, sees a framed newspaper clipping celebrating the opening of the diner and the waitress says it’s sad a family died in 19-whatever year it was and dumps a bit of exposition so the audience is beaten over the head with what Melody’s arc is, setting up her redemption at the end. Maybe also a scene where Phoebe probes about this and we see Melody turn slightly scary when her emotions flare up.
-
Cut the scene with Garraka talking to Melody in the street. It wasn’t needed at all and deflates the twist.
-
I like the library sequence in the movie… but this could easily have taken place at a new location. I would’ve picked a museum as featured in the games/cartoon and instead of the lion statue coming to life, have possessor animate a skeletal T-Rex. Budget allowing…
-
I wish the CG budget stretched to animating the possessed Ecto a little more. But not much you can do with that inside the firehouse tbf. Was little more than a cool reference.
-
Structurally and in terms of marketing I think audiences felt the frozen empire concept was wasted, it came too late in the movie and we didn’t see enough of the city due to budget restrictions. I would therefore have put a pin in that concept for now but keep most everything else, replace Garraka with…
-
The build-up of energy in the containment unit causes interdimensional tears or attracts the attention of a demon who wants an army of ghosts, and while benched at the PRC Phoebe discovers they need to transport ghosts to the afterlife Melody talked about, rather than holding them in stasis inside a giant trap. Phoebe fixes Egon’s mistake as ghosts cannot be held indefinitely and at the end of the movie creates a new containment unit which is effectively a trans dimensional gate or pocket dimension a la Real Ghostbusters. There is no Frozen Empire.
You could have a subplot with Callie & Trevor where he’s not cleaning up after himself as some sort of analogy (but idk make it funny!). Theme of responsibility etc.
The same end point could be reach whilst keeping the Frozen Empire theme, but as Tyler pointed out it doesn’t need to be an ice age, could just be snowing in July, would’ve had the same impact and freed up the CGI budget for elsewhere in the movie.
Many good points raised so far in this thread.
For my change, and this might sound harsh, I would invent a time machine, go back in time and tell Gil to write a better script, since everything can be traced back to this (which the directing didn’t solve and editing didn’t fix).
:sigh:
Can we get the Frozen Empire threads included in the recently updated topics shortcuts now?
Can we get the Frozen Empire threads included in the recently updated topics shortcuts now?
We’ll check with AJ, he’s the only one who can do that.
Some great suggestions in here and I can’t remember what my original changes were that inspired the thread.
Firstly, I love Frozen Empire as it is. That said it clearly didn’t hit for all fans / critics, and there are glaring areas for improvement. These are changes I agree with or would’ve made.
I agree with giving Lars’ role at the PRC to Lucky, with Lars supervising but taking a back seat… then give Hubert’s exposition role at the Library to Lars. Patton is great but unless they have a plan for him as a future cast member he isn’t needed here. Although he does flesh out the idea Ray has pals in the city, which is a nice bit of world building tbf.
Montage. When Phoebe gets benched and the others get called out… we need a montage to show Phoebe, Podcast and Ray bored around the firehouse intercut with Gary and Callie busting 3-4 ghosts. This ticks several boxes missing from the movie and injects some brief action.
Phoebe investigating the Melody Diner fire, sees a framed newspaper clipping celebrating the opening of the diner and the waitress says it’s sad a family died in 19-whatever year it was and dumps a bit of exposition so the audience is beaten over the head with what Melody’s arc is, setting up her redemption at the end. Maybe also a scene where Phoebe probes about this and we see Melody turn slightly scary when her emotions flare up.
Cut the scene with Garraka talking to Melody in the street. It wasn’t needed at all and deflates the twist.
I like the library sequence in the movie… but this could easily have taken place at a new location. I would’ve picked a museum as featured in the games/cartoon and instead of the lion statue coming to life, have possessor animate a skeletal T-Rex. Budget allowing…
I wish the CG budget stretched to animating the possessed Ecto a little more. But not much you can do with that inside the firehouse tbf. Was little more than a cool reference.
Structurally and in terms of marketing I think audiences felt the frozen empire concept was wasted, it came too late in the movie and we didn’t see enough of the city due to budget restrictions. I would therefore have put a pin in that concept for now but keep most everything else, replace Garraka with…
The build-up of energy in the containment unit causes interdimensional tears or attracts the attention of a demon who wants an army of ghosts, and while benched at the PRC Phoebe discovers they need to transport ghosts to the afterlife Melody talked about, rather than holding them in stasis inside a giant trap. Phoebe fixes Egon’s mistake as ghosts cannot be held indefinitely and at the end of the movie creates a new containment unit which is effectively a trans dimensional gate or pocket dimension a la Real Ghostbusters. There is no Frozen Empire.
You could have a subplot with Callie & Trevor where he’s not cleaning up after himself as some sort of analogy (but idk make it funny!). Theme of responsibility etc.
The same end point could be reach whilst keeping the Frozen Empire theme, but as Tyler pointed out it doesn’t need to be an ice age, could just be snowing in July, would’ve had the same impact and freed up the CGI budget for elsewhere in the movie.
Yes! The Melody in the street scene totally ruins the twist. That’s such a good point. That would play way differently and also solve other problems. I bet that was a reshoot. I’d bet money on it.
I also agree with the montage. It’s weird a ghostbusters movie not having a montage. That would add so much.
I really like this movie. But it’s mostly for the character work. The villain just feels like such a big nothing. The marketing made it seem like this was going to be a big epic Ghostbusters movie and it’s shocking how little happens.
And the “bust” is easily the worst bust of the franchise. The Afterlife Muncher bust just owns this. We went from one of the best busts to one of the worst and we don’t really get anymore until the end. And the ghost looks pretty lacklustre I’ll be honest. Compared to Muncher? Scoleri Bros? Slimer?
I think they shouldn’t have started that sequence in medias res. I would’ve liked to see a sewer worker encounter the ghost. Freak out. Gets out of the sewer, says to his co worker who saw the creature fly out “We gotta call some one!” and in the most overly dramatic way the co worker says “Who? Who are we gonnna call?” The worker gets a wry smile on his face when BLAM! The GB logo hits. Ray Parker Jr croons.
You know the suit up scene in at the start of Batman Forever? We see Batman putting on his costume, selecting his weapons and tools, in a series of cuts? They should cut from the GB logo to that. Boots go on. PKE meter goes in holster. Elbow pads. Proton pack removed from charging port. We don’t see who is doing this.
Then we see the Ecto 1 lights light up, the siren wails and VROOOM. She roars to life and heads out on the call.
Then we continue on pretty much the same. Only maybe there should have been TWO sewer dragons. Two Mates. “It’s mateing season” Or a mom and her baby. Something like that. Something to add more dynamic action.
Cause there just isn’t enough busting. Enough cool busting.
Now the old films don’t have much busting either but they didn’t blow their busting load in the very first scene.
I also wonder why they cut the Garraka freezing Lucky scene down. the trailers made u think she was gonna die almost but they cut it waaay down. The trailer had this super creepy shot of her eyes.
What frustrates me about this movie is with a few tweaks, some extra money, this could’ve been the best one. Ok. Maybe not the best one. But awesome.
I never felt the budget get in the way of Afterlife. Not once. This movie? BIG TIME.
But all the ingredients are there. Kumail is great and funny. It’s almost like there’s too many good characters and just not enough time. I’d love to see more of Ray and Podcast. More Podcast and Phoebe.
It’s not that there are no montages, it’s the two montages aren’t like the pairs of montages in GB1 and GB2. Both of those had the first with the Ghostbusters on various cases then ghosts of all kinds terrorizing the city. FE does not use this model. In FE, one comes super early and is a montage of Statue of Liberty gb2/Ray Parker/merch. The other - Coney/Chinatown is just Death Chill spikes. edit: and the lengths are too short. Even that Afterlife one with the ghosts felt too short. The lack of an official soundtrack goes hand in hand, too, as they used songs from them for the montages in GB1 and GB2.
Yeah, Melody in the street was reshoots in Atlanta. I have to look at my notes but I think the buildings are a giveaway for their various reshoots on Peacethree in downtown Atlanta.
I guess test audiences needed that extra link to hammer the connection between Garraka and Melody.
It’s been a year since Frozen Empire’s release, but to this stay I still have conflicting opinions on it. I really want to absolutely love it (and I do in some aspects), but there’s a lot of things that drive me up the wall about it.
For starters, and this is probably my biggest gripe with it, the new equipment never got the time to shine it so desperately deserved. Nobody except Pheobe, Lucky, and Lars wore the Red Parkas, the HASP Packs and compact Throwers played next to zero part in the plot (they weren’t even used to catch/eliminate a ghost!), and the Ecto Z was kind of a let down in terms of design. This is not to say that I hate the new equipment, far from it, as I’m actually in the process of making a HASP Pack myself, and I have an Alexgear Parka. Deleted scenes seem to suggest that they would’ve been utilized more, and if that were the case, then I’d be very curious as to what earlier versions of the film would’ve looked like.
The Containment Unit subplot was an extremely disappointment. Firstly, I HATE how Garraka was able to breach it open, once again destroying the firehouse and unleashing his army of ghosts that was warned about in the trailers. It makes the ending super bittersweet for obvious reasons. Who’s to say that there weren’t some entities in the ECU that were just as/if not more dangerously powerful and malevolent as Garraka? What if Gozer and the the Terror Dogs were inside it? (Though I have a theory that the new Containment Unit in the Engineering Lab was specifically designed so that the Traps from Egon’s house could be simultaneously emptied, hence why it has so many bays and cartridge slots). I know that they did this solely to set up sequels, but come on man!
The whole “Pheobe’s too young to be a Ghostbuster” subplot is also extremely dumb. Not because I think Peck should’ve never barred her from being one, but that he’s entirely right. Ghostbusting can be an extremely hazardous job, as we all know, and that minors probably shouldn’t be the ones doing it. And when she finally is allowed to do so once again, what kind of message is that supposed to tell to the audience? That child labor laws don’t apply as long as you’re passionate enough for the job? What part of that makes sense?
Finally, there’s Garraka’s (faulty) plot armor. Garraka himself as to be one of my favorite Ghostbusters villans to date. I’ve always wondered what a snow/Christmas themed entity and/or plot would look like, and he almost completely scratches that itch… this his Cardi B sized fingernails and all that… Anyways, I think he’s super intriguing, since he not only wields the ability to freeze people to nearly absolute 0 degrees kelvin, plunge the world around him into artic weathe, but can also forcefully control other ghosts and paranormal entities into doing his bidding. BUT… and this is a big but, his plot armor is his downfall. This mainly stems from the fact that he can freeze standard Proton Streams. The effect and idea is cool, but that instantly rendered the new Packs useless, and if you weren’t going to have them play a big role in the plot, why did you go through all of that effort to redesign them??? (Unless they will finally get their time to shine in whatever sequels come after this. Only when Pheobe brass plates the Cyclotron components (and booster tube I think? It’s not stated) does the Proton Stream do anything, but even then, Garraka was able to overpower her, causing her to be frozen too (sidenote, how has nobody who’s been frozen by him managed to survive? Besides the vape store guy, of course.) But then of course, Melody comes in and gives Nadeem some fire, and then he proceeds to roast Garraka. That’s another point… HOW DOES FIRE CAUSE HARM TO GARRAKA, BUT NOT A PROTON STREAM THAT SHOULD IN THEORY HAVE A LOT MORE ENERGY AND POWER THEN FIRE??? That’s why I call his plot armor “faulty”. Basically, the final battle scene just showed that the Ghostbusters didn’t need to handle this, as if Nadeem has any relatives with him who also had the Firemaster gene, they could’ve easily kicked his male donkey. Yeah… just the kind of stuff I want to see in my GHOSTBUSTERS MOVIE. What’s next, the revelation that you could beat Garraka up with a pair of brass knuckles?
With all of that out of the way? Do I hate Frozen Empire? Absolutely not. For one thing, I don’t hate any Ghostbusters movie (yes, that includes 2016), but also I feel as though it could’ve been something much better. So, how would I rewrite it?
For starters, I think that Pheobe should not have been the main character, due to the aforementioned “Pheobe’s too young to be a Ghostbuster” subplot. She could still be helping around the Firehouse, doing odd jobs like helping Janine, cleaning out Ecto-1, or maybe even emptying Traps into the Containment Unit. Meanwhile, she may also be balancing stuff like summer school, college prep, etc. Of course, I’d still want her to play a role in the final battle, but not the main good-guy. In her place, I’d want Trevor to be the main character. After all, Pheobe got her time in the spotlight, now I think it should be Trevor’s turn. For example, that if he was the one in the Gunner-Seat in the beginning of the film, while somebody else controlled the R.T.V.? (Maybe Pheobe, Idk). What if Trevor was the one being stalked by an (aged-up) Melody. Maybe he’d go to Lucky for help, and they’d both try to confront her, but end up causing some big calamity like how Pheobe and Podcast did at the diner. I’m not entirely sure how the whole “Garraka being released” part would play out with him, but either way, I think having him as the main character would be a huge upgrade.
Secondly, I’d get rid of the whole Containment Unit subplot of it having a limit as to how many ghosts could be stuffed inside it. I forgot to mention this earlier, but that was also one of my big gripes with this film. It makes Egon look like an incredibly short-sighted, dimwitted guy, which they clearly showed in Afterlife not to be anywhere near close to the case. Instead, I think a better explanation for its design would be something more akin to The Real Ghostbusters, where the inside of it was basically a different dimension that was either an infinite, or extremely large, capacity (i.e. the Sun would explode before the Containment Unit would get full). Also, Garraka would not be able to breach it open in a way that all the entities inside it would be able to escape, rather only enough so that he’d be able to be sucked inside it once they reversed the polarity.
Finally, both Garraka and the final battle would be heavily reworked. Garraka would retain most of his abilities with the exception of his Proton Stream immunity, but that wouldn’t come into play until the end. At first, Garraka would be able to freeze Lucky’s Proton Stream as he did in the film, and during the beginning of the battle. However, when he’s about to bust open the ECU completely, Trevor walks up the basement stairs, and flips his Proton Pack into Composite Particle System mode. That’s right, instead of a brass-plated Pack, he’d be wielding a TVG Pack! Much like the brass Pack, I’d wanted it to be hinted at throughout the film. In this case, I’m thinking that when Lars is showing off the blueprints for the Containment Unit and other Ghostbusters equipment, Trevor or Pheobe spots a blueprint for a pack labeled “rejected”. Upon furthermore investigation, it turns out to be blueprints for various Proton Pack upgrades Egon had thought up and designed, but were rejected for potentially being too dangerous. Whoever, someone (Maybe Pheobe) takes interest in these, and decides to add them on to a spare Pack. Somehow, this upgraded Pack ends up in Trevor’s hands right before Garraka shows up, and he proceeds to March up the stairs to kick Garraka’s honey, in this case, with the Meson Collider/Overload Pulse. By some miracle, it does some damage, causing him to be distracted from breaching open the ECU. The blast of Meson particles is hot enough to crack Garraka’s layer of ice that coats his body, which Proton Streams simply can’t. Then of course, Garraka hits Trevor with his ice breath, freezing him in place, yadayadayada, Melody and Nadeem come in to help, but in this case, Nadeem’s firepower also caused Garraka’s ice layer to melt, and once the other Ghostbusters are unfrozen, he’s completely vulnerable to Proton Stream attacks. Then it becomes a huge curfuffle of Nadeem, Trevor, the rest of the Spenglers, and Gary zapping and capping Garraka. Meanwhile, the OGs rush down to the basement to reverse the polarity of the Containment Unit, sucking Garraka into it, and sealing itself shut. Light is green, the whole world’s clean, Melody apologizes to Trevor for manipulating him and bringing about the apocalypse, she crosses over, and everyone does the Whip and Nae Nae. The end.
Is my little fanfic perfect? No. I could say and add more to this, but I’ve been writing for the past hour, and I’m tired. I hope somebody likes it.
Keep the deleted scenes in. The deleted scenes are all gold.
Implement more Venkman throughout (we know his shots got cut out of the PRC intro scene)
Keep the sequence of the OGS capturing the possessor ghost “that took some talent!” — No need for the reshot version in the kitchen.
Other than that the movies grown on me.
Keep the deleted scenes in. The deleted scenes are all gold.
The deleted scene with Ray, Janine, the Spenglers, Gary, Lucky, Hubert and Nadeem is definitely a keeper and should’ve been in the final cut… But I feel the scene with Peter and Gary was rightfully cut. I don’t have an issue with the idea behind it, but I feel Bill’s lines (if he was working from a script rather than ad-libbing) and his delivery were just not up to expectations (Having re-watched it, Paul and Bill’s vibes feel like they clash, Paul’s playing Gary being worried/a little scared, while Bill seems too laid back - maybe it’s meant to be a stress/defence reaction, but the two conflicting approaches leave the scene feeling a little awkward).
I feel Bill’s been batting 500 in his scenes as Peter, sometimes he’s spot-on (Interviewing Nadeem, “Tall, dark and ■■■■■ at 12 o’ clock”, “Ray, pretend I don’t”, “Just do it! We all trust you”), and then other times he feels more like Bill riffing on himself (when Peter arrives at the Firehouse, his chat with Gary in the deleted scene, and most of his performance in Afterlife.)
I don’t know if it’s his limited screen time that’s resulted in it taking him so long to get back into the groove of portraying Peter Venkman (almost certainly not helped by Murray’s infamous unpredictability and difficulty to work with), or if he’s just not been trying as hard as he could to re-embody the role, but he’s lagged behind Dan and Ernie in channelling their old characters.
And I feel this was also evident back in 'The Video Game (when he could actually be bothered to record his dialogue). There were moments where the Peter Venkman we knew did rear his head, and when he did, he shone… But other times he was strangely softer-spoken, and it even felt like he wasn’t really trying… Dan, Harold, Ernie, Annie, William and Brian and Alyssa brought their A-game, whilst Bill’s felt the weakest at times.
I don’t know if featuring more Peter Venkman scenes is the answer when Bill is being Bill, and when he seemed a little off his game. If anything, I’d probably have featured a little more of Gary.
I like the idea of a scene with Peter and Gary having some sort of brief chat, but I think there could’ve been a better version of it than what we got… Like maybe they have a heart-to-heart that covers both Ghostbusting, and being a step-dad?
GARY:
How did you know if you were doing it right?
PETER (he shrugs):
Sometimes you just have to take a step back, and see what happens… Y’know? If the kids aren’t acting like hell hounds or Vigo’s ■■■■■■■ little brother, then you’re doing okay… If they feel comfortable talking to you about the big stuff, then you’re probably doing better than me.
I guess I just feel that the scene between the both of them should’ve been more than just Peter joking about grabbing a shave and going to a club. ![]()
I do feel that using Pheobe as the focus character again wasn’t the right angle.
If anything, we should have followed Gary around more on busts and having his role as the “new crew lead” and “father figure” would have made for a more layered story where everything Pheobe was going through can be seen through his lens.
But that’s more of a writing critique.
With going off of the footage we know we have…I’ll just vote for more OG time.
I already posted I would have had Ray, Phoebe and Podcast be more of the focus since they were the ones left out of everything. In addition to the library, hang out the firehouse, go on unofficial calls, etc.
About child labor and Peck being right…just wanted to say there’s 2 kids at one of my local grocery stores that help out and bag stuff. I’d say they’re like 11 or 12 years old. Maybe younger. It’s been about a year. It really surprised me at first cause I thought is this allowed?
Still a little awkward when they’ve offered to help me with my food. Haha. I’m always polite though. They seem happy to be working. I guess it’s fine since it’s pretty basic work. You have to assume cops and such have gone in and seen them. It’s not a secret.
About child labor and Peck being right…just wanted to say there’s 2 kids at one of my local grocery stores that help out and bag stuff. I’d say they’re like 11 or 12 years old. Maybe younger. It’s been about a year. It really surprised me at first cause I thought is this allowed?
Still a little awkward when they’ve offered to help me with my food. Haha. I’m always polite though. They seem happy to be working. I guess it’s fine since it’s pretty basic work. You have to assume cops and such have gone in and seen them. It’s not a secret.
That sounds more like extremely shady business on your local grocery store’s part, but even if it weren’t, bagging some old lady’s apples is a lot different than hanging off the side of a motored veichle and shooting at eldritch horrors with compact Particle accelorators lmao
Honestly, I felt that this and After Life lacked Winston interaction with the cast in general.
In After Life, he interacted with Peter and Ray (that’s a given), and Janine. Outside of that, the car. lol But I figured it was the end of the movie, so didn’t think much about it.
And FE, I loved the scenes with him, Ray and Peter. And him scolding Phoebe on destroying the lion statue. But I would have loved him just talking to her one-on-one, especially after that dig at her mom about not being a scientist, and therefore not really being a GB. That would be a good time for Winston to relate to her how the other three had scientific backgrounds while he was from the military. But that didn’t make him less of a GB.
Idk. I know I’ve complained about the lack of Winston, even more now that he funds the company, but it was something that stood out to me.
Also, more Gary and the life of being a GB. I love that enthusiasm.
Edit: Additionally, the ghost. Like, the CU blew up again and released a ■■■■-ton of ghost. I would have loved to see the Scoleri Bros or something other than generic phatoms. And the toothy one from the new CU enclosures. The story from that bust had to be terrifying.
Thats why this movie should have been simplified to the highest degree.
The trailers and the logline were simple enough—the OGs lend the new crew the ropes at the firehouse. Simple and clean. Keep it narrowed down to just the OGs and afterlife crew. Allows room for more character moments with the characters we love.
The character arc should be Gary as the focus, also keep Rays “golden years” arc.
Nadeem and Melody added a unique elements to the GB lore, however their inclusion could have been saved for the next movie as for “this” one..they added to the common complaint of “too many characters”
But oh well
Yeah, would have neat if they mentioned why Garraka didn’t bother with breaking open the new ECU at the PRC i.e. “Gozer’s in there, guess Garraka didn’t want to deal with any competition.”
Good point, Gary being the focus in FE would have been a nice parallel track of sorts to Ray’s big arc. Both doing what they love but grappling with their other roles. Gary ghostbusting and parenting, Ray not settling for retirement from ghostbusting. But Reitman and Kenan appear to be keen on Phoebe’s arc taking place over 3 movies then whoever takes over as director can focus on whomever. Hope Winston gets a big focus in next one like Ray got in FE.
Agreed, the Dark Horse comics have a smaller cast and that really helps. But still a bit of a juggle with who has delineated arcs and who’s just there.
Yeah, would have neat if they mentioned why Garraka didn’t bother with breaking open the new ECU at the PRC i.e. “Gozer’s in there, guess Garraka didn’t want to deal with any competition.”
Not enough ghosts in the P.R.C. E.C.U., I’d assume.